icrn phw energy cse dte gobar times rwh csestore iep aaeti

Beyond a flailing state

Posted on: 29 Mar, 2013

Finance Minister Palaniappan ChidambaramRecently, I heard Dulitha Nandanie Fernando, emeritus professor of community medicine at the University of Colombo, speak about how Sri Lanka had managed to orient the country’s health system towards women. The island nation’s record on slashing infant and maternal mortality rates (MMRs) is well known, an achievement that has over the years led to much breast beating over India’s snail-like progress on these parameters. What Fernando had to tell at the Public Health Foundation of India’s annual day lecture is something that many of us know already. But it bears repetition because the solutions this country is debating (endlessly) seem to ignore some basic facts.

The most important factors behind its outstanding success are: 1) Sri Lanka provides a truly public health system in which the state is the main provider of services, all free, to which everyone has access. The input from the private sector is insignificant; 2) everything works at the field level from the public health midwife to specialist hospitals and; 3) there is universal access. But, underpinning this, Fernando emphasised, is the political commitment to implement welfare measures.

And here lies the rub. What does one do without this political commitment, when we have, as in most crucial sectors of public welfare, a minister who is missing in action? The way out then is to talk about public private partnerships if not privatisation of a service that is the fundamental responsibility of the government. Fernando, using 2008 statistics, put India’s MMR per 100,000 live births at 230 compared with Sri Lanka’s 39. According to the latest (2010) figures, the  corresponding figures are 200 and 35 for these neighbours. What it means is that India doesn’t have any hope of meeting the Mille nnium Development Goal target of 109 by 2015.

The lack of commitment at the highest levels and the absence of a work ethic have lead to a widespread system crisis here. US academic Lant Pritchett had an interesting explanation for why things go so shockingly awry in India, and why it is incapable of implementing programmes and policies. He calls this the flailing state syndrome, “a nation state in which the head, that is elite institutions at the national (and in some states) level remain sound and functional but that this head is no longer reliably connected via nerves and sinews to its own limbs…” As a result, nothing works, because field level agents of the state, from health workers to teachers and engineers, are increasingly beyond the control of the government, at state and national level. “In police, tax collection, education, health, power, water supply—in nearly every routine service—there is rampant absenteeism, indifference, incompetence, and corruption. As this is true of even relatively routine services, even more so for more sophisticated ones like networked irrigation or groundwater management.”

Pritchett, an economic research and development practitioner who teaches at Harvard’s Kennedy School of Government, gives the example of absentee public health workers in Rajasthan and the attempts made to cut this down by a system incentives and penalties. Nothing worked, and absentee levels remained the same, forcing patients to seek help elsewhere. The better-off went to private doctors; the poor went to quacks. Is this an intractable cultural trait? Is it a work ethic fashioned by our ethos and upbringing in a society that is collective? Pritchett terms flailing as the inability to maintain sufficient control of the administrative apparatus to effectively deliver services through the government “in spite of democracy and strong capability at the state level”.

But Pritchett, I think, is misled by seeing strong capability at the head. That is an illusion. Take tax collection, where we fail as abysmally as with health services. We’ve just had the budget for 2013-14. In this, Finance Minister PalaniappanChidambaram says there are only 42,800 of the affluent in this country who admitted to a taxable income exceeding Rs.1 crore annually and these were the only source from which the state could raise res ou r ces. Really? A couple of months earlier, the ministry had told the parliamentary standing committee looking at its functioning that it could recover just three per cent of the total tax arrears of Rs.249,000 crore.

While the minister bewails his lack of options, the Economic Survey released just a day before his budget shows that giveaways have made the government finances even more parlous. “The magnitude of revenue foregone (tax expenditure) is indeed high,” it says. “In the Receipts Budget for 2012-13, tax foregone on account of exemptions under corporate income tax for 2010-11 and 2011-12 was estimated at Rs.57,912 crore and Rs.51,292 crore respectively net of MAT.”

It’s not just the limbs of government that are not functioning, but also its head. We have gone way beyond Pritchett’s definition of the flailing state.



Privatization of health sector will have far-reaching consequences in the long-run. Business men in health sector not only make profit, but also make orindary people debt-ridden, thus ensure a motal blow that will finish him permanently.

23 April 2013
Posted by
ajith muruvelil

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

(Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.)

Sign in to post

More Blog Posts by Latha Jishnu


Glacier hydrologist at International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development based in Nepal
Institute of Public Health, Bengaluru
Senior advocate at Supreme Court of India
Convener of Alliance Against Conflict of Interest
Professor of Economics and Social Sciences at Indian Institute of Management, Bangalore
Senior associate of the Asia Program at Rights and Resources Initiative
Medical practitioner
CSE Affiliate (Right to Clean Air Campaign)
Programme Manager, ICIMOD
Resource Specialist, ICIMOD
Research Associate, CSE
Sustainability and CSR practitioner
Senior researcher with Accountability Initiative at the Centre for Policy Research in New Delhi
Director, Policy Research & Advocacy, with Child Rights and You (CRY)
Environment Research and Action Collective (Himdhara) HP
Executive Director, National Foundation for India (NFI) and is also the convener of National Social Watch Coalition
Associate Director, Media Resource Unit,CSE
Freelance reporter
Engagement Coordinator and Researcher, Project Survival Media
Environmentalist with a long association with the Appiko movement in Uttara Kannada
Consultant with the CSE
Deepak Pani is secretary, Gram Swaraj, Baripada, Mayurbhanj, Odisha
Works for non-profit South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers and People (SANDRP)
Architect and urban designer with the CSE
Rationalist and president of the Federation of Rationalists Association of India
Bidyut Mohanty is founder and secretary of SPREAD, based in Koraput
Researcher with the Nature Conservation Foundation
Affiliation: Fellow, Rights and Resources Initiative
Independent researcher
Research Associate, Industry & Environment (CSE)
Phd candidate, UC Berkeley’s College of Environmental Design
Senior Programme Manager, Regional Centre for Development Cooperation
Director Programmes, Keystone Foundation
Senior Research Associate, Industry and Environment, CSE
RBI Chair Professor of Economics
Sustainable Finance Project Officer
Assistant Professor, TISS, Mummbai
National Institute of Malaria Research, Guwahati
Director of Indian Institute of Public Health, Gandhi Nagar
Manager of Médecins Sans Frontières's Access Campaign in India
Gujarat-based environment activist
Consultant, CSE
Independent researcher working on poverty, public public policy and governance
Programme Officer, Renewable Energy Programme at CSE
Researcher with the Centre for Equity Studies in New Delhi
South Asia Program Director at International Rivers
Policy Director at International Rivers
Independent Weather Forecaster, METD WEATHER
National Chairperson of the Council of Canadians and former UN water expert
Project Officer, International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD)
Renewable Energy Expert
works with Shola Trust, a non-profit involved in nature conservation in the Nilgiri region of South India
Trustee, Save Animals Initiative Sanctuary Trust, Karnataka
Activist and researcher
Activist and researcher
Programme director (HealthBridge Foundation of Canada)
Programme Director, CSE
Professor, NIUA
Earth system scientist
Consultant, Social Sector
Food and nutrition consultant
Assistant Professor, IG Medical College, Shimla
Programme manager, Food Safety and Toxins, CSE
Associate Professor of Environmental Sociology at the University of Wisconsin at Eau Claire, USA
Visiting professor of economics at Mount Holyoke College, USA
Former Deputy Director at the National Institute of Nutrition Hyderabad
Works with indigenous groups in the Nilgiris and writes about dalits and other marginalised communities
Convenor and Head of Jiye Yamuna Abhiyan
Managing Trustee, Wildlife First
Fellow and Convenor, Centre for Environment and Development Studies
Associate Professor, Ambedkar University
Shuba V Raghavan is an independent energy policy analyst
Professor and Dean, Faculty of Planning, CEPT University
Senior reporter, Down To Earth
Reporter, Down To Earth
Senior Research Associate, CSE
Senior researcher with CSE
Doctoral Candidate, ATREE, Bangalore
Programme Officer, Renewable Energy Programme, Centre for Science and Environment (CSE)
Co-director, Anthra
Director, Research Centre for Internet and Society
Programme Officer, Right to Clean Air Campaign (CSE)
Research Associate, Green Rating Project (CSE)
Senior Research Associate Waste Management, CSE
Senior Research Associate
Conservation ecologist
Conservation ecologist
Research Associate
Heads the Division of Policy Planning, and Training & Capacity Development at India's National Institute of Disaster Management at IIPA campus in New Delhi
DG, Amity Institute for Herbal and Biotech Products Development
Associate Global Co-ordinator of the Peoples Health
Senior Fellow with SOPPECOM, Pune
Heads League for Pastoral Peoples and Endogenous Livestock Development
Principal Scientist with NISTADS, New Delhi
Co-founder, Nature Conservation Foundation
Assistant Professor, IISc
Science communicator with Vigyan Prasar, New Delhi
Chief Copy Editor, Down To Earth
Environment Research and Action Collective (Himdhara) HP
Reporter, Down To Earth
Programme Director, CSE
Wildlife biologist
Senior Editor, Down To Earth
Deputy Programme Manager, CSE
News Editor, Down To Earth
Science Editor, Down To Earth
Senior Editor, Down To Earth
Secretary with Vikas Samvad Human Development and Food Rights Resource Center
Deputy Director General, CSE
Features Editor, Down To Earth
Postgraduate student of Wildlife Biology and Conservation at the National Centre for Biological Sciences
Editor, Down To Earth
Follow us ON
Follow grebbo on Twitter    Google Plus  DTE Youtube  rss