
it is good to eat as many as vegetables and fruits (totally vegetarian), but my aurvedic doctor asked me to stop eating every...
Standard texts mention perepheral role of nutrition in therapy of tuberculosis.Perhaps this is done to emphasise the role of...
Angry villagers from the hotbed of political violence told Sayantan Bera, the day a new government took oath in West Bengal
A phone call early in the morning relieved me of the tension. The general strike called by the Maoists is for tomorrow and day after. Today, I will be able to visit few villages inside Jangalmahal. A contiguous patch of forest crisscrossing three districts of south West Bengal, the area came into limelight in November 2008.
Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee’s convoy was targeted with a landmine set up by the Left insurgents. What followed was violence from all sides: a hunt down by the state police, fierce resistance from the people, and the government establishing its right to rule and govern at gunpoint.
Uneasy reactions to the camera inside Jangalmahal. In the foreground are drying Sal leaf plates- a lifeline for the residents. |
On May 20 as West Bengal swore its first women Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee, ending 34 years of an elected communist government, we whizzed past a sculpture of Karl Marx, standing tall beyond the winding flyover overlooking the bustling district headquarters of West Midnapore. Witness to many a season of political irony. Banned Left wing groups fighting tooth and nail the erstwhile rulers of the “official” Left, with the “new” Left of Mamata Banerjee emerging victorious on the plank of ma maati manush (mother, motherland, the people).
Inside the Chandra forest range, the villages wear a sleepy look, oblivious of the change of guard in the state capital of Kolkata. Unlike in the nearby Midnapore town, there are no loudspeakers blasting “sonpapdi meri sonpapdi”, nor could I spot a single poster of Mamata Banerjee. Of the 14 assembly seats in Jangalmahal, Banerjee’s Trinamool Congress has won seven. A massive inroad into the Left-front bastion without even a basic organisational set-up. While the losing Left-front alleges the victory is a “gift” from the Maoist rebels, the villagers tell a different story.
Residents of Jharia village say how acutely they are dependent on forests for their survival. The rain-fed single crop of paddy is grown in the infertile red soil and yields a produce that lasts barely six months. The adjoining Sal forests are their lifeline. It supplies them with fuelwood and an array of medicinal plants and fruits. Under joint forest management, they occasionally get a share from the timber sold by the forest department. Women work for 16 hours in a day to collect, dry and knit Sal leaves into plates. A stack of 1,000 plates sell for Rs 100 and is the only regular cash income.
“But come elections, the forests are looted,” says Gopal Mahato angrily, sitting under the shade of a banyan tree next to the forest. There is a crowd around and everyone starts talking. “Usually this happens before every elections but this time it was rampant. Fearful of losing they went on a rampage and we had a hard time protecting our patch of forest.” The result is most visible in the fringe forests which are close to the highway. The vegetation is bushy with new shoots sprouting out of the felled coppice Sal trees. Day before, a range officer had told me a similar story “off the record”: “It was difficult for me to protect the forests. We would patrol through the night but as the local police was busy with the elections we could do very little. Besides you cannot dare touch the ruling party cadres.” The casualties: unestimated truckloads of Sal and Mahul.
Jharia residents inside a patch of forest they fiercely protected |
But how could just a few people do this while others were resisting? Politics, harmads (armed cadres), and the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF), the residents told and explained the process. “The Maoists came in 2009 in these areas riding on the wave of popular resistance in Lalgarh. They would tell us that we need to protect our jal, zamin, jangal (water, land and forests) and stopped felling altogether. They would not even allow the forest department to do the regular felling in selected patches.”
“To counter their influence the CPIM (ruling left parties) brought in harmads. It was easy: whoever protested would be branded as Maoists. The CRPF will come with the state police to our village, arrest and beat us up. There was no place we could go to seek justice. District CPIM leaders gave a diktat that no forest produce from Jangalmahal would be allowed to be sold outside. We had to pay Rs 500 fine to reach the town with livestock or Sal leaf plates. Outside agents stopped coming to our villages to buy chickens and goats. It was a living hell.”
“After the elections we feel relieved that we can at least speak out. If you were here a year ago none of us would have the courage to talk.” According to the villagers of Jharia the atrocities reached a tipping point on November 14, 2010 when a large group of harmads came early morning. The men ran to the jungles to save their lives. Twenty-four-year-old Nibaran Singh was the only one who could not run. Injured in his left foot, he could barely walk. The armed cadres, his brother Sunil said, dragged Nibaran to the forest and shot him dead.
Sunil shows the spot where his 24-year-old disabled brother was shot dead. His mother Sandhya is in the foreground |
Later as I would leave Jharia, Sunil would follow our car and stop us. He asked me to get down and said, “I want to show you the place he was shot.” We started walking. His mother Sandhya was sitting inside the jungle near a bush. Sunil showed the “spot” and said the police have erased the complaint. “What can I do now?”
A bunch of youngsters took me on a tour of the nearby forest. After pointing out to the medicinal properties of a handful of different plants they handed leaves of a creeper locally known as sugar pata to cure diabetes. “If you chew these you cannot even taste the sweet in anything for two hours. On your way back chew these and then buy some sweets so you would know we are not lying.” In the nearby paddy field they pointed to elephant paw marks from last year. Herd of elephants regularly raid these areas when the paddy is ripe in the fields. “We could not even burst crackers to chase them out. Else the CRPF would come in the morning and arrest us saying we are all Maoists hurling bombs and bullets. So last year when a herd of 70 elephants came in the morning we chased them through the entire day. All of us got together, and by evening we chased the herd straight into the CRPF camp. We worked hard, a few walls in the camp were razed down, but it was fun.”
A man returns after collecting fuel-wood from the forests |
Back to the hotel in Midnapore town, I switched on the television. The new Chief Minister has declared a special economic package for Jangalmahal and promised she will soon take a decision on withdrawal of “joint forces” from the area.
O
P
E
N
Dear Sayantan,
you are doing some interesting work without any shade of doubt. Two main (related) criticisms about the left(CPM): a) try to govern at the gun point and b) lack of right to talk are pointed out by you quite successfully. However, your sample may not necessarily represent the entire West Bengal and hence your analysis, in my view, suffers from the very common disease of over-generalization.
I also personally know some people who have got some voice because of the left and got minimum freedom and some sense of liberty because of the left agenda. However, that also does not prove anything. The point is not to pretend to be 'apolitical'. The way politically loaded terms like 'official left' and 'new left' or 'harmads' etc. are used, I am afraid that they may actually weaken your points.
Love & Regards
Surajit
Surajit Das
Praiseworthy honest effort! While 'jangalmahal' was in the news for all relevant and irrelevant political reasons, this issue has been largely overlooked by the mainstream media and even the political parties.
Have you read the book "Red sun: travels in Naxalite country" by Sudeep Chakravarti? The authors shares the same feeling. Once again it proves that whatver be the socio-political justifications in favor and against this social unrest, the problem stems from the eternal conflict between haves and have nots.
Prabirendra Chatterjee
A smooth even headed narration, paints a stark picture of how deep and wide the CPM tentacles of terror had spread Mamata is change indeed but i wonder if she really has a concrete political and economic programme beyond mere rhetoric
By the way, i best liked the part where the villagers chase a herd of elephants into the CRPF camp, could not contain my laughter then. What a way to take revenge on the state.
Saumya Dey
Well written Sayantan............yes, this pretty much portrays the picture of Jangalmahal.......they were oppressed to no ends....lets see what the new govt does.......i think the way the villagers drove the elephants into the CRPF camp is a serious thing which tells one to think deeply after the initial jerks of laughter.....now, they have rammed into the oppressive forces and drove them out for good...
tiasa
Very relevant and well written article. The "red corridor" always reeks of exploitation and oppression. The Indian Forest Act, The Wildlife Act and The Land Acquisition Act- these three much misused Acts of Govt. of India have push the problem beyond the tipping point. Sayantan, don't know if you got a chance to ask the villagers about the details of sharing of proceeds of sale from timber under JFM. It would be interesting to know thier views on this as it is often claimed that JFM has been quite a success in West Bengal.
Param
Paramjyoti Chattopadhyay
Another good work Sayantan. Your article is a new way to look into the life of the people of ‘Jangalmahal’ and thus learn the problems they face. The atrocities faced by them from the hands of ‘harmard’, state police and CRPF has sidelined one big issue- the forest. It is really awkward to know that during election when the armed forces are much higher in number in the areas, the forests are looted maximum at that time only. From your article it is clear that in the last 34 years, fruits of development have not reached to these people. Policies were adopted, but only a few were implemented. Out of 29 blocks of West Medinipur, 18 are backward. The story is almost the same for Bankura and Purulia districts too. But the Left Front government did not pay any attention to develop those areas in the last 34 years, rather chose to rule at the gun point.
Here I would also like to mention about your photographs. They clearly portray the land and her people; their simple but struggling life, their losses, and their curiosity to something foreign. Great effort indeed.
Biswarup Ghosh
The governance pattern of the CP(I)M in Bengal lately has been monolithic and dictatorial, and the blind interest/ego of the "party" being placed above all. It's a shame that a party indulging in such brute force(s) has a plebeian undertone!
Conservation of the forests and it's resources is anyway a big challenge. It will be interesting to see how that is addressed by the new administration politically and economically. As you mentioned, a special economic package has been announced, but at the same time the issue of managing forest resources and ensuring livelihoods for the locals needs "bottom up" policy measures through the empowerment of local people.
Srestha Banerjee
Thank you all for taking the time out to read through and for putting forth your observations.
@Surajit- I have tried my best to put across what the local villagers from Jangalmahal told me. This is certainly not the whole of West Bengal and is only about people living in territorial forests. Situated in three adjoining districts of West Midnapore, Bankura and Purulia. I went to a division of West Midnapore and have stopped short of making a generalisation. However, if you read through national magazines like Tehelka which has covered the region consistently for the last three years, you'll find out the scenario. Another thing, I am not apolitical as you have put it but at the same time is wary of falling into broad categories I took recourse to.
@Prabirendra- I agree with you. The national media has never gone beyond the violent 'events' of Jangalmahal to look into how the people spend their days there. Thier livelihood and the constant threat from the state looming large. Thanks for refering to 'Red Sun', its one of the best books on Maoist insurgency in India.
@Tiasa, Saumya- I am glad you liked reading the piece and especially the elephant episode. Lets hope they will be spared the violence in the coming years.
@Param- I was actually there to report on an upcoming cover story on JFM. Good that you already pointed it out. You'll see an evaluation of the whole programme with reportage from more than five states soon in Down To Earth.
@Biswarup, Srestha- Yes, we can only hope the new government delivers. But development in today's India only tantamounts to more conflicts. And more often than not we impose our views of 'development' on the people without listening to what they want.
Posted by
Sayantan Bera
sayantan
there is this sense of deja vu for me, when i read your article. very poignant picture of the harsh reality of being a tribal. being torn in between the ultra left, sadly the left too and in my state, the ultra right. the story is always of this one man paying the price for what he has not done. but i think in WB what makes it worse, is the Left goondas stealing the NTFP, which is something I have not seen in other states. its disappointing for left supporters like me, but alas the truth. Great story. Keep it up.
Madhumita
Madhumita Ray
The area has given birth to Joint Forest Management which is now followed by Govt. of India all over the country. Paschim Midnapore has always been a successful example of JFM. It was good to read about the initiatives of the villagers there to protect the forest. At the same time, one feels sad on their exploitation by the politicians. Lets hope that the new state government would do the needful to restore peace and livelihood oppprtunities in this beautiful land of red soil and sal forests.
Sejuti Sarkar De
Post new comment