icrn phw energy cse dte gobar times rwh csestore iep aaeti

Mark Lynas and the demeaning of science

1 Comments
Posted on: 30 Jan, 2013

He’s fuzzy on facts and low on science, but the campaigner gets big media support

imageWithin days of his address to the Oxford farming conference on January 3 where he claimed he had been wrong in opposing GM crops, environmental activist Mark Lynas’s speech had gone viral, attracting an avalanche of comments, the brickbats perhaps outweighing the fulsome praise. Down To Earth, too, was alerted to the speech but I, for one, was foxed by the headline-grabbing mea culpa. One knew vaguely that Lynas was a climate campaigner who had changed his views to accommodate the concept of planetary boundaries—if humanity operated within the boundary framework on 10 parameters we could continue to exist as we’ve done in the past 10,000 years—and had written The God Species to explain his new thesis. According to the thesis, climate change is “more than anything else, a financing issue”. So why were a lot of people getting hysterical about the Lynas speech on having seen the light on GM crops?

Two sets of people are fulminating over the claims made by the activist. One lot is the anti-GM activists who, justifiably, are questioning his claim that he “helped to start the anti-GM movement back in the mid 1990s”. If he did so then not many knew this. One of his claims, made in an interview to The Indian Express, which has outraged activists here is that he coordinated the anti-GM campaign with Indian NGOs, “in the process taking the fear of GM crops to India”. But what is odd is that the anti-GM Saul converted to the GM-is-the-solution Paul at least two to three years ago, and hence the excitement of the media worldwide is a little curious to say the least.

Even more surprising is the reaction of Indian newspapers; most of them have grabbed at Lynas’s Oxford speech with a delight—or is it desperation?—that is hard to fathom. Ironically, it is the very same dailies that took pains to highlight Prime Minister’s recent remark at the Indian Science Congress: “Complex issues, be they GM food or nuclear energy or exploration of outer space, cannot be settled by faith, emotion and fear but by structured debate, analysis and enlightenment. A scientific approach and understanding of these issues are therefore as vital as our core scientific capabilities.”

What does Lynas have to say that is scientifically valid? This is where the other set of people who have been upset by his contrition come in. These are scientists, and highly reputed ones, who have been withering in their criticism of his understanding of science. This is important because Lynas says the reason he is no longer hostile to GM crops is because he “discovered science”. This column does not have the space to detail the frailties of Lynas on the science of GM. Scientists like Doug Gurian-Sherman, a doctorate in plant pathology and senior scientist with the Union of Concerned Scientists, and John Vandermeer, professor at the department of ecology and evolutionary biology in University of Michigan, have ripped apart Lynas’s sweeping and naive claims and what appear to be deliberately inaccurate portrayal of the GM technology.

Here are some of the more egregious examples: according to Lynas, the world needs GM because other methods are inadequate to meet the planet’s food requirements. Here’s what Gurian-Sherman has to say: GM may contribute, but conventional breeding continues to outpace GM and is likely to do so in the future. Besides, agroecology is much better at addressing many of these issues because of pressure on finite resources and the resilience required. The other myth Lynas fosters is that GM has been instrumental in reducing pesticide use. A recent study by Charles Benbrook shows the biggest promoter of GM crops, the US, is using much higher amounts of pesticide on account of GM herbicide-resistant weeds, mismanagement, and the monoculture system of GM technology. As anyone keeping tabs on GM knows, resistance to Bt by rootworm in the US is increasing and will lead to higher insecticide use. In other parts of the world, too, insect-resistance is mounting: by the stem borer in South Africa and bollworm in China. All of these are issues that Lynas does not deign to address.

Ultimately, Lynas and what he says should not matter to us: not to the scientists, to the activists or to the media. But what’s worrying is the reluctance of the Indian scientific establishment to acknowledge the downside of GM technology. Worse still is the determined refusal of the mainstream media, specially the business dailies, to make an effort to understand the issues surrounding the issue. The scientific illiteracy of journalists is well known. Should they then be relying on the likes of Lynas to push their agendas?

AddThis

A brilliant summation of the issues raised in the assorted emails one is getting on Mark Lynas . After spending 40 years on environmental issues - as CEO of WWF India and a Vice President of the Bombay Natural History Society for 2 decades, and on several Govt Committees - I must confess that I had never heard of Mark Lynas in the GM context - and even on the climate change issue his impact in India was perhaps confined to very few. So his claim on influencing the anti-GM movement in India, at least, seems to be untrue, but certainly a very effective PR exercise by the GM lobby! Glad there are some publications that have not been carried away by this rather irrelevant 'mea culpa' -and are trying to engage with the real issues surrounding GMOs.

4 February 2013
Posted by
Dilnavaz Variava

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.


(Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.)

Sign in to post

Contributors

Engagement Coordinator and Researcher, Project Survival Media
Environmentalist with a long association with the Appiko movement in Uttara Kannada
Consultant with the CSE
Deepak Pani is secretary, Gram Swaraj, Baripada, Mayurbhanj, Odisha
Works for non-profit South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers and People (SANDRP)
Architect and urban designer with the CSE
Rationalist and president of the Federation of Rationalists Association of India
Bidyut Mohanty is founder and secretary of SPREAD, based in Koraput
Researcher with the Nature Conservation Foundation
Affiliation: Fellow, Rights and Resources Initiative
Independent researcher
Research Associate, Industry & Environment (CSE)
Phd candidate, UC Berkeley’s College of Environmental Design
Senior Programme Manager, Regional Centre for Development Cooperation
Director Programmes, Keystone Foundation
Senior Research Associate, Industry and Environment, CSE
RBI Chair Professor of Economics
Sustainable Finance Project Officer
Assistant Professor, TISS, Mummbai
National Institute of Malaria Research, Guwahati
Director of Indian Institute of Public Health, Gandhi Nagar
Manager of Médecins Sans Frontières's Access Campaign in India
Gujarat-based environment activist
Consultant, CSE
Independent researcher working on poverty, public public policy and governance
Researcher with the Centre for Equity Studies in New Delhi
South Asia Program Director at International Rivers
Policy Director at International Rivers
Independent Weather Forecaster, METD WEATHER
National Chairperson of the Council of Canadians and former UN water expert
Project Officer, International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD)
Programme Director, CSE
works with Shola Trust, a non-profit involved in nature conservation in the Nilgiri region of South India
Trustee, Save Animals Initiative Sanctuary Trust, Karnataka
Vice-president
Activist and researcher
Activist and researcher
Programme director (HealthBridge Foundation of Canada)
Programme Director, CSE
Professor, NIUA
Earth system scientist
Consultant, Social Sector
Researcher
Journalist
Food and nutrition consultant
Assistant Professor, IG Medical College, Shimla
Programme manager, Food Safety and Toxins, CSE
Associate Professor of Environmental Sociology at the University of Wisconsin at Eau Claire, USA
Visiting professor of economics at Mount Holyoke College, USA
Former Deputy Director at the National Institute of Nutrition Hyderabad
Works with indigenous groups in the Nilgiris and writes about dalits and other marginalised communities
Convenor and Head of Jiye Yamuna Abhiyan
Managing Trustee, Wildlife First
Fellow and Convenor, Centre for Environment and Development Studies
Associate Professor, Ambedkar University
Shuba V Raghavan is an independent energy policy analyst
Professor and Dean, Faculty of Planning, CEPT University
Senior reporter, Down To Earth
Reporter, Down To Earth
Research Associate, CSE
Doctoral Candidate, ATREE, Bangalore
Co-director, Anthra
Director, Research Centre for Internet and Society
Programme Officer, Right to Clean Air Campaign (CSE)
Research Associate, Green Rating Project (CSE)
Conservation ecologist
Conservation ecologist
Research Associate
Heads the Division of Policy Planning, and Training & Capacity Development at India's National Institute of Disaster Management at IIPA campus in New Delhi
DG, Amity Institute for Herbal and Biotech Products Development
Associate Global Co-ordinator of the Peoples Health
Senior Fellow with SOPPECOM, Pune
Principal Scientist with NISTADS, New Delhi
Co-founder, Nature Conservation Foundation
Assistant Professor, IISc
Science communicator with Vigyan Prasar, New Delhi
Chief Copy Editor, Down To Earth
Reporter, Down To Earth
Programme Director, CSE
Wildlife biologist
Senior Editor, Down To Earth
Deputy Programme Manager, CSE
News Editor, Down To Earth
Science Editor, Down To Earth
Senior Editor, Down To Earth
Secretary with Vikas Samvad Human Development and Food Rights Resource Center
Deputy Director General, CSE
Features Editor, Down To Earth
Editor, Down To Earth
CSE WEBNET
Follow us ON
Follow grebbo on Twitter    Google Plus  DTE Youtube  rss