Indian anti-corruption drives don't factor in the poor, the worst victims of the scourge
In late 2015, when Indians were desperately waiting for the new Union government to act on its anti-corruption agenda that helped it to come to power, this column concluded: “As many say, an anti-corruption campaign is better experienced than explained” (see “The Forgotten Class”, Down To Earth, 1-15 November, 2015). It was an assessment on how the high voltage anti-corruption campaign translated into action after more than a year of the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) coming to power. At that time, popular anti-corruption leader Arvind Kejriwal was settling down as Delhi’s chief minister after a landslide win. What then, has been the Indian’s “experience” with the anti-corruption agenda in the last two years?
Corruption has come back into the spotlight in recent weeks. Again, it is due to big players duping the government and public of big bucks. In more than one way, it reminds one of the 2012-14 phase with corruption allegations crossing billions. Headlines are scarily similar; government reactions even more so. Recently, global anti-corruption watchdog Transparency International ranked India as Asia-Pacific’s most corrupt country. In fact, the trajectory of massive scams coming out is also similar. Like last time, there is disillusionment about the economy and middle class drawing room rumblings have started. But this column won’t deal with that.
Irrespective of who rules and how much public money is siphoned off, India’s anti-corruption drive fails its worst victims, the poor. It is widely known that the poor, despite having no self-sustaining capacity, pay for accessing basic services which otherwise should be their entitlement. Transparency International says seven out of 10 people pay bribes to access public services. But we tend to focus on corruption only when big cases of fraud come to light. There is hardly any discussion on day-to-day corruption that mostly impacts the poor. Why? Because such corruption is more about quality of governance and is thus a statement on a regime’s effectiveness. Bribery for accessing healthcare in a district is more about a near-collapse of governance. Ideally, this is a much more electorally damaging scenario. But we don’t see a popular uprising over this. Rather, politicians cleverly use it to polarise voters on the rich-poor matrix.
Let’s look at demonetisation. The NDA government claims this as its biggest step to weed out corruption though it hardly had any visible impact. But it did create a perception that the rich were impacted the most. The poor endured it initially with a self-inflicted sense of taking revenge on the rich. It served the politicians’ purpose the best. After a year, the poor are now back to bribery to get basic services. The recent survey finds that Indians bribe the most for accessing health and education services. And 73 per cent of bribes paid in India came from low economy groups, the report says.
Similarly, in response to the recent bank fraud cases, the government has embarked on raids and property seizures that hardly suffice for the money laundered. But, again, by declaring these as “stringent” steps against the rich, the government is just polarising rich and poor.
But the poor are no more buying this. Farmer protests, petitions on linking Aadhaar to all basic facilities and forces uniting on a broad platform to take up the poor’s issues are indicators that only cosmetic steps to weed out corruption won’t help. Rather, the demand is now to deliver development. That is the right way to fight corruption impacting the poor.
The article was first published in March 1-15, 2018 issue of Down To Earth
Cost of corruption
Weeding out corruption
Poor countries have remained poor, says World Bank
Judgement of the Supreme Court of India regarding coal block allocation cases, 23/01/2017
Tyranny of MGNREGA’s monitoring system
The Lokpal and Lokayuktas (Amendment) Bill, 2016
Judgement of the Supreme Court of India regarding grant of voice telephony to Reliance Jio Infocomm Ltd., 08/04/2016
Judgement of the Supreme Court of India regarding appointment of people as Ministers to the Council of Ministers of Union of India despite their involvement in serious and heinous crimes, 27/08/2014
We are a voice to you; you have been a support to us. Together we build journalism that is independent, credible and fearless. You can further help us by making a donation. This will mean a lot for our ability to bring you news, perspectives and analysis from the ground so that we can make change together.