SC bans dirty pet-coke, furnace oil in Haryana, Rajasthan, UP; CSE lauds verdict

The order comes in response to the recommendations of the EPCA that has found very high sulphur levels in these fuels

By DTE Staff
Last Updated: Tuesday 24 October 2017

The court has directed industries to comply with the first ever NOx and SOx emissions standards by December 31. Credit: PixabayIn a landmark ruling today the Supreme Court bench comprising Justice Madan B Lokur and Justice Deepak Gupta banned the use of dirty furnace oil and pet-coke in Haryana, Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh from November 1, 2017. This ban is already in place in Delhi. The bench has further directed the Ministry of Environment and Forests and Climate Change (MOEFCC) to notify the standards for nitrogen oxide (NOx) and sulphur oxides (SOx) for the industry sector and the industry has to comply with the standards by December 31, 2017. In addition, the MOEFCC will have to pay a fine of Rs 200,000 to the Supreme Court. The Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) lauds this directive as a big win for Delhi and NCR as well as the rest of the country fighting a tough battle against toxic pollution.

This order has come in response to the findings and recommendations of the Environment Protection (Prevention and Control) Authority (EPCA) that has exposed widespread use of these fuels in industrial sectors of NCR and found very high sulphur levels in these fuels, ranging from over 20,000 PPM in furnace oil to over 64,000 PPM in pet-coke. Use of these fuels was banned in Delhi way back in 1996. Furnace oil and pet-coke are the dirtiest by-products and residual fraction from the refinery process.

Significance of the new directive

Eliminates dirtiest industrial fuels in Haryana, Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh and mandates first ever stringent NOx and SOx standards for the industry sector nationwide: This momentous order eliminates in one stroke the use of dirtiest bottom of the barrel fuels from the industrial units of the neighbouring states of Uttar Pradesh, Haryan, and Rajasthan and makes all industrial units across the country liable for compliance with the new emissions standards by December 31, 2017.

Enormous pollution reduction potential from the industrial sector: This action has high potential for pollution reduction as large number of industrial units in Ghaziabad, Faridabad, Bhiwani, Noida and Greater Noida, Hapur, Bulandshahar, Alwar, Jhajjar, Gurugram, Rohtak, Mewat, Sonipat, Rewari, Palwal, Karnal, Meerut, Muzaffarnagar are currently using these dirty fuels.

This order will have nationwide impact as the entire industrial sector will have to comply with the new standards for SOx and NOx that are not regulated currently in India.

New order to offset adverse effect of perverse incentives allowed to dirty fuels under GST

The intervention of the Supreme Court is very opportune and timely as the recently enforced GST has created huge incentive for these dirty fuels to thrive. Both these fuels are included in GST and are in the 18 per cent tax bracket. But the industries, which use these fuels for manufacturing, get a credit. The tax of 18 per cent is fully credited to industry. But for the cleaner option, natural gas, which is not included in GST, the VAT is as high as 26 per cent in Uttar Pradesh.

The incentive for dirty fuel is fanning and expanding the use of dirty fuels. Demand for pet-coke has increased to such an extent that last year India imported 14 million tonnes of pet-coke, which is more than the domestic production. If import and domestic production is added, then India has used more pet-coke than China, when its pollution was at its peak.

Today, China has stopped imports of pet-coke. But India has become a dumping ground of pet-coke from the US, which has banned its internal use because of pollution.

Implementation will have to be the priority now

All the concerned agencies will have to focus on implementation of the order. In fact, the EPCA had filed its first report on the matter in April 2017 asking for expansion of the ban on use of furnace oil and pet-coke, which was already in force in Delhi, to the rest of NCR. In the due process of hearing, the MoEF&CC made a plea saying that instead of ban, industries should be allowed to adhere to emission standards.

Harish Salve, senior advocate and Amicus Curiae, brought to the notice of the apex court that there are no emission standards for SOx and NOx for industries. In response, the Supreme Court, on May 2, 2017, directed that the SOx and NOx standards be issued by CPCB/MoEF&CC by June 2017. In July, the MoEF&CC sought time. But industries were put on notice that they would need to comply with standards by December 31, 2017.

Today, the MoEF&CC submitted to the Supreme Court the draft standard for emission standards for SOx and NOx, which was issued on October 23, 2017. The CPCB submitted affidavit saying that they had sent proposed standards to the MoEF&CC on June 27, 2017. For two industrial sectors, Nitric Acid and Fertilizer, proposed standards were sent in 2014. Clearly, the process of setting standards was caught in a time warp. The honourable judges of the Supreme Court were not amused by this inexplicable delay in setting standards for pollution control.

India has continued the use of these extremely polluting fuels without any regulation for too long. Any further delay in standards and implementation of the court order will make air pollution and health risk worse. Implementation of the directive from the Supreme Court today has to be the top agenda for pollution control and we must take act urgently.

Subscribe to Weekly Newsletter :
Related Stories

Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.

  • Dear all, At the outset , It is welcome move of the Apex court banning these dirty fuels. Use of used dirty oil in firing is fraught with danger leading to ugly consequences. Coming to pet coke , to a great extent , it is failure of ministry of coal in providing adequate good quality coal from their mines at reasonable rates and thus is responsible for use of pet coke in india as alternative to it. Government needs to review its coal policy and ensure that good quality coal at reasonable rate is provided to MSME sector who will suffer severely on account of impkementation of SC order. Rapida action is request in larger public good in tune with business philosophy and policy of sustainable development. Jai hind.....AK Bhargava,Katni, MP 9425157452

    Posted by: Arvind Kishore Bhargava, Katni , MP | 2 years ago | Reply
  • both centre and state govt are sleeping over the issue of pollution. No steps are being taken for a permanent solution. strict measures need to be taken to make delhi livable.
    traffic jams/snarls to be checked by better maintenance of roads, clearing roads from encroachments/ parkings, developing alternate routes/roads where space is available.
    all diesel vehicles must be banned in NCR
    Railway must shift transit traffic from delhi to nearby areas
    de-congestion of delhi by shifting wholesale trade to nearby areas.
    strict implementation of existing laws and orders from SC/NGT/other courts.

    Posted by: Common Man | 2 years ago | Reply
  • The primary fault behind this state of pollution lies with the various government bodies; the various Pollution control boards exist solely to get their monthly packets from the industries, while the various NGOs focused on Climate Change seem to be interested only in conducting seminars and providing lip service. Lets not forget that India has an excess of both Petcoke and FO which are refinery byproducts, while we have to import almost all the gas at considerable cost.
    Banning any fuel outright is a ham-fisted approach that would only increase the stockpiles of FO and petcoke in the country and drive up commodity costs. Instead my not convert the Petcoke into Carbon Slurry Fuels and Emulsify the FO. Both are mature technologies which reduce NOx by 30 to 50% and can also be use tweaked to include SOx reducing sorbents into the emulsion.

    Posted by: Ravi Deka | 2 years ago | Reply