Bt brinjal controversy hots up in Bangladesh

Bt Brinjal farmers divided between green activists opposing GM crops and government which claims the crop experiment was fairly suiccessful

 
By Reaz Ahmad
Last Updated: Monday 17 August 2015

Activists have questioned government authorities for showing haste in propagating Bt brinjal (Photo courtesy Ubinig)

More than eight months after Bangladesh began Bt brinjal cultivation the government and anti-GM activists are locked in a war of words. Neither of the two groups is showing any sign of backing down.

In the latest development, the Bangladesh Agricultural Research Institute (BARI) in Dhaka has invited the 20 farmers involved in cultivation of GM brinjal to tell their story to journalists on Sunday. The move is reportedly meant to counter the green groups who invited seven of these farmers to talk about their crop failure and demand compensation.

The anti-GM protesters were jubilant when a Bangladesh court blocked the move to release South Asia's first genetically modified (GM) food crop in September last year. But their happiness was short-lived because within weeks the government succeeded in obtaining a court order favouring the release of Bt Brinjal.

The Bangladesh government released Bt brinjal on October 30 same year and handed over saplings of the four GM brinjal varieties to a select group of 20 farmers on January 22 this year.

The move to release Bt brinjal in Bangladesh came at a time when two other Asian countries—India and the Philippines—having the same GM crop (Bt Brinjal) technology ready in hand, refrained from doing so because of legal hurdles and people's opposition.

One thought the debate over Bt brinjal in Bangladesh so many months,  but the fight between pro- and anti-GM lobbies has, in fact, escalated.

Over half of these 20 farmers are upbeat about the yields they got from the maiden cultivation of Bt brinjal that they say do not require pest-killing sprays thanks to a bacterial gene expression that keeps fruit and shoot borers (FSB) at bay.

FSB is the most destructive insect pest for brinjal in South and Southeast Asia. A large percentage of brinjal does not make it to the market because of FSB infestation that can render a high 70 percent of the crop unusable. Overdose and improper application of pesticides on brinjal to fight FSB, make these vegetables harmful to consumers.

But the remaining (some say seven, some say nine out of the 20 farmers) have been complaining about poor yields they got from the Bt Brinjal cultivation. Green groups gave voice to them by arranging press briefing and bringing in the farmers from the countryside to the national capital.

Director General of BARI, who pushed Bt brinjal cultivation initiative, Md. Rafiqul Islam Mondal, does not agree that Bangladesh's GM crop pilot has gone awry.

Mondal explained, "Bt brinjal is no silver bullet. It's meant for resisting FSB. That trait doesn't necessarily mean Bt brinjal will not be susceptible to bacterial wilt or for that matter, certain other vulnerabilities."  (See 'What's the fuss about Bt brinjal').

Green groups like Ubinig, led by Farida Akhter, say the government rushed into introducing GM food crops in Bangladesh and all the prerequisites have not been followed properly, as is expected, while pursuing such frontier sciences.

Shahjahan is one of the 20 farmers chosen by the government for first farmers' field trial of Bt brinjal. He is from central district of Jamalpur.

Shahjahan gave three reasons why he did not get expected yields from Bt brinjal.

"They (government) gave us the plants late in the season (in January instead of October-November); the plants were kept in very dry conditions prior to being supplied to me; and the variety that I got is not suitable for my type of soil. Had they supplied me Kajla (variety) instead of Noyontara it would've clicked well."
Shahjahan, a quite understanding person, who doesn't want to see himself in either of the leagues of the protagonists or the antagonists, said, "There is no question of compensation for whatever crop losses some of us have suffered. We actually got both financial and accessories' supports from the government in the first place," the farmer said.

He is willing to try out Bt brinjal one more time provided government gives him quality seeds/plants at the right time in right condition.


Report: The status of commercialized Bt Brinjal in Bangladesh

Subscribe to Weekly Newsletter :
Related Stories

Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.

  • If Bt Brinjal or for that

    If Bt Brinjal or for that matter any GM crop with embedded toxic gene is so safe for cultivation why do scientists prescribe 'refuge clause' that makes smallholder farmer stand on his head to balance his livelihood and food security options?

    Posted by: Anonymous | 5 years ago | Reply
  • There are a lot of safe, eco

    There are a lot of safe, eco friendly and cheaper alternative to chemical pesticides and GM/ bt crops to control pests. We fail to evaluate our own indigenous Brinjal varieties. It is 3868 in India and Indian Subcontinent. Many varieties were resistant to insect and disease. FSB( Fruit and Shoot Borer) is not a major pest in Brinjal in all the seasons specially in winter months. Thrips, green jassids, mite, mealy bug and wilt are the major pest and disease in chemical farms. These are not a problem in organic farms with mixed cropping,brinjal is cultivated with other companion crops. It was the tradition and wisdom of the farmers of the Indian subcontinent and that agricultural wisdom have been vanished from the farmers fields along with externalization of agricultural inputs. Bt Crops are hoax , full of lies, an instrument for cheating the farmers in the name of science. Failure of the crop is due to FARMERS and occasional so called-success is due to CORPORATE SCIENCE which has been blown up to a big proportion to attract media.

    Posted by: Anonymous | 5 years ago | Reply