Amitav Ghosh argued that there is a systematic silencing of non-partisan voices on the issue of climate change
Climate change is a behemoth we must not ignore, and its veracity should not be contested. This was the premise of the discussion between Sunita Narain, director of Centre for Science and Environment, and Amitav Ghosh at the release of the author’s new book, The Great Derangement, at India Habitat Centre on July 19.
Taking a cue from Ghosh’s book, Narain said that despite experiencing the impacts of climate change all around us, how do we manage to look the other way? Pointing out that dealing with climate issues is considered a fringe activity, Ghosh observed that contemporary literature is also not talking about climate change. “There's complete silence in imaginative discourse when it comes to climate change issues,” said the author.
Agreeing with Ghosh’s observation on how we have systematically turned away from discussing climate change impacts, Narain said, “We are beginning to close the circles of conversations on climate change. This is the kind of intolerance we are seeing these days.” While talking about the failure of Paris Climate talks, which moved away from climate justice issue, Ghosh argued that there is a “systematic silencing of non-partisan voices” on this issue.
Referring to Gandhij’s ability to envisage a society that would try to adopt an unsustainable lifestyle, Ghosh said that we have universalised a model of lifestyle that cannot work for the majority in the face of climate change. The author lamented the fact that our overt dependence on technology is creating a situation wherein we have started seeing technology as a savior. Ghosh’s argument was further augmented by Narain when she said, “We cannot wait for a disruptive technology to save us from climate change impacts. We need a just and equitable way to cut emission.”
Delving into the challenges that India faces globally, Narain said that the voice of India and other developing countries is not yet strong enough to influence the global discourse on climate change issue. “Today, we are powerless because we are not asking our leaders to take action,” she said.
When India is already in the throes of extreme weather events and institutions are yet to make any progress on tackling them, what’s the road ahead? “There is a need to take the discourse on climate change away from the purview of bureaucrats and experts,” said Ghosh. According to Narain, “Scientists have to work with society and explain extreme weather events in a way that everyone understands.”
During the Q&A, some important ideas were exchanged in the realm of climate change education in schools. In reply to whether climate change can find a mention in the electoral politics of India, Narain said that government has started responding to the agitation of farmers who are affected by extreme weather events and this is just the beginning.
We are a voice to you; you have been a support to us. Together we build journalism that is independent, credible and fearless. You can further help us by making a donation. This will mean a lot for our ability to bring you news, perspectives and analysis from the ground so that we can make change together.
Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.