Shooting to kill
The killing of a Blackbuck and
Chinkara by Salman Khan and other
film stars in the very heartland
of the Bishnois has come as a rude
shock to many animal lovers.
The offenders were lucky to have
escaped, for had the Bishnois, caught
them, they would not have been
alive today.
The Bishnois are the well-known
guardians of the wild. For them,
animals are not merely endangered
species, they are like their own children. They worship Sant Jambeshwar
and live by his 29 edicts. His teachings,
among other things, call for the protection of wildlife against poachers or
hunters. They belong to the warrior
caste and are god-fearing vegetarians
and custodians of the dumb and
helpless creatures.
Down To Earth deserves special
praise for publishing the report
'Reel-heroes and real ones' (Down To
Earth, Vol 7, No 12; November 15).
Film stars should learn a lesson
from this incident and should
also follow the example set by the
Bishnois. They must realise, that
if they want to shoot animals, they
should do it with the camera and not
with the gun.
AMARJIT SINGH
Bathinda, Punjab
After reading about Salman Khan's
disgraceful shooting of the Blackbuck
one realises the wisdom of the old
saying: they ought to shoot more actors
and less films.
R P SUBRAMANIAM
Delhi
...
The price of going nuclear
I believe that the government and
the traders are responsible for
the rise in the prices of essential
commodities in India. The government
has a nexus with traders and the
media must expose this nexus. The ban
on onion exports should have come
immediately after the news of the
shortage. But the government chose
not to do so. The ban was imposed only
after the traders had exported their
stocks and earned profit. Today, the
common people are made to suffer due
to the contamination of mustard oil
and the spiralling prices of essential
commodities like onions. The air
quality in most cities is deteriorating.
Tomorrow, we might even have
to pay for oxygen. In my opinion, the
rising prices of essential commodities is
a result of the worsening economic cri-
sis in India. One factor that has aggra-
vated this economic mess is the sanc-
tions that were imposed in the after-
math of the nuclear tests, which
India conducted on May 12 1998.
One must ask this question: "Do we
need nuclear weapons - weapons
that have not only shattered peace and
killed thousands, but pose a serious
health risk to living beings the world
over?"
...
Unscientific alternatives?
The article 'Fuel for thought' (Down
To Earth, Vol 7, No 10; October 15)
says that "renewably grown biomass
is a co 2- neutral fuel with a low
sulphur content" and that "little
is said about using trees and other
forms of biomass as an energy source
to substitute the use of Co 2 emitting
fossil fuels."
Both these statements are
incorrect - neither is all biomass
necessarily low in sulphur, nor
are all fossil fuels necessarily high in
sulphur. As far as pollution is
concerned, there is not much difference
between them.
Another article in the same issue,
'Power pedaling' by Anil K Rajvanshi
advocates the use of electric cycle
rickshaws, advising that "the govern-
ment should make it mandatory that in
congested areas in big cities only
electric rickshaws... should ply". The
article goes on to state that "the cost...
is prohibitive for India". It also fails to
acknowledge the severe environmental
pollution caused indirectly during the
manufacture of electrically-powered
vehicles.
These articles reflect a simplistic
perception, bordering on naivete
that most scientists hold for alternative
energy sources. One is reminded
of the common perception that
ayurvedic medicines are non-toxic
and do not have adverse effects unlike
their allopathic counterparts. The
reality is that whereas the toxicity
of allopathic medicines is carefully
assessed and documented, no such
exercise is done for most ayurvedic
medicines.
About 25 years ago, when I began
working on renewable energy sources,
too believed that the mentioned alter-
natives are clean and cheaper than the
conventional sources. Today, I am
not sure.
...
A clarification
This is with reference to my interview
'Women know how to manage better'
(Down To Earth, Vol 7, No 13;
November 30). There were two errors
in the interview. I was posted as a chief
executive officer, zilla panchayat and
additional collector (development),
Sagar, Madhya Pradesh (mp). I was not
transferred from Sagar for taking a
proactive stand on the participation of
women in Rural Development
Programme. As a matter of fact, I had
mentioned in my interview the support
of the mp Government in this project.
On my personal request, the govern-
ment of mp had granted me a deputa-
tion and I was not transferred from
Sagar.
...
Expose the corrupt
In the article "The
method behind the
madness" (Down to Earth,
Vol 7,
No 11; October 31), Anil
Agarwal and
Sunita Narain have
rightfully pointed
out that corruption "has
made a mockery of the entire system
of governance,
democracy and
development".
The country is already
mired in
corruption. It is time
the general public
voiced their
displeasure. One way of
spreading awareness
about the ills of
corruption would be by
writing more
often about issues
concerning corruption in magazines and
newspapers. I
would request you to
publish such articles on a regular basis
in Down To
Earth. It could serve as
an eye-opener
for the general public
and perhaps force
implicated officials and
bureaucrats to
change their ways.
...
Errata
In the special report
'Left hanging'
(Down To Earth, Vol 7,
No 13;
November 30), it was
inadvertently
mentioned that heavy
vehicle manufac-
turers Ashok Leyland and
TELCO offered
their buses to the Delhi
Transport
Corporation (DTC) for Rs
90 lakh each.
TELCO did no such thing.
Our apologies
to the vehicles of the
said company.
...
We are a voice to you; you have been a support to us. Together we build journalism that is independent, credible and fearless. You can further help us by making a donation. This will mean a lot for our ability to bring you news, perspectives and analysis from the ground so that we can make change together.
Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.