Mining in Goa: damage to the environment greater than loss of revenue

Activists demand assessment of impact of mining on state's environment and communities

 
By Ashwin Aghor
Last Updated: Thursday 17 September 2015

Illegal mining in Goa is being projected as a bigger scam than Bellary. While revenue losses from illegal mining has been estimated at about Rs 3,000 crore, the loss by way of damage to the environment and loss of livelihood has not been estimated.

An estimated 100,000 people living in the villages in four talukas in north and south Goa have lost their source of living
Their farms have been destroyed by mining silt and water sources have been contaminated
Mining has caused irreversible damage to forests, agriculture, fisheries and water aquifers
Goa has 90 operational mines spread along the Western Ghats in an area of 150 to 200 sq km. Most of the legal and illegal mines are in forest areas
A Raja, now in jail in connection with the 2G spectrum scam, issued 169 environment clearances for mines in Goa between 2005 and 2009 when he was the Union minister of state for environment
 
Take the instance of Caurem village in Quepem taluka in south Goa. It has 2,000 families whose farms have been destroyed by illegal mines operating in the area. The silt from mining has entered the fields which now  resemble a large quagmire. Tukaram Velip, a resident says that the perennial stream that irrigated the village fields is polluted and agriculture has been completely destroyed. People are left with no means of earning their living, he says.

Most of the mines in the state are concentrated in four talukas—Bicholim in north Goa, and Sattari, Sanguem and Quepem talukas in south Goa. Activists say that an estimated 100,000 people living in the villages in these four talukas are affected. Besides loss of livelihood, they are also suffering from the adverse effects of air  noise and water pollution. “Mining has caused irreversible damage to forests, agriculture, fisheries and water aquifers,” says Abhijit Prabhudesai, member of Goyencha Xetkarancho Ekvott (GXE), a non-profit in Margaon city. He says the government has allowed mining even in forest areas despite the presence of wildlife.

The mining has also affected the Salaulim dam on the Salaulim river in Sangeum taluka, which supplies drinking water to half the state's population, besides providing water for irrigation and to industries. Over 20 mines are operating in the vicinity of the dam. Heavy silt has settled in the dam reservoir because of  mining. An official in the state water resources department admits that mining has damaged the state's water resources and says the department is now reassessing the life span of the Salaulim dam. The dam was commissioned in the 1970s with an expected life span of 100 years. A study conducted by The Energy Resources Institute (TERI) in 1994 showed excess iron and manganese levels in the Salaulim reservoir water. “This was when mining was at a much lower scale as compared to present level of mining. We have repeatedly asked the government to conduct a study on water availability and quality, but nothing has been done till date,” says Prabhudesai. 

image

Superintending engineer with the water resources department, S V Prabhavalkar says there is little his department can do. “Mining is carried out under the laws of the Central government. All state laws are overruled by Central laws, and there is hardly anything we can do with limited powers and resources,” he says. “Our powers are limited to issuing notices to offenders. It is the office of the collector which is supposed to take punitive action,” he adds.   

A Raja's gift to Goa mining companies

At present, Goa has 90 operational mines spread along the Western Ghats in an area of 150 to 200 sq km. Most of the legal and illegal mines are in forest areas.
Former Union minister A Raja who is now in jail in connection with the 2G spectrum scam, issued 169 environmental clearances for mines in Goa between 2005 and 2009 when he was the Union minister of state for environment, says Claude Alvares of non-profit Goa Foundation. He says this was a record in itself. Of these, 15 clearances were for mines inside the Netravalli wildlife sanctuary in south Goa. “Even the Union ministry does not have have copies of all these clearances. We could obtain only four, the rest are missing,” says Alvares.

Goa's additional chief principal conservator of forest, Shashi Kumar, however, denies that mines are operating in protected areas. “There were a few mines in the Netravalli and Madhei sanctuaries, but all of them were closed three years ago,” he says. He adds that the forest department also taxes mining companies that use forest roads to transport ore. “Earlier mine operators were charged at the rate of Rs 50 per metre of road length. We have now increased the fee to Rs 200 per metre,” he says. The permission to use the existing roads are subject to the condition that the roads would not be widened and trees would not be cut, says Kumar.

image

The mines in Goa are allowed to produce a total of 60 million tonnes of ore annually. The excavation ratio in Goa is 1:3 (for every tonne of ore, three tonnes of soil is extracted), which means ore extraction would lead to extraction of 180 million tonnes of soil every year. “Considering that most of the mines are in the Western Ghats, one can well imagine what would happen given the current pace of mining,” says Alvares. According to the records with the mines and minerals department, mining in the state touched 55 million tonnes in the financial year ending March 2011 as against 45 million tonnes the previous year. The mining business in the state is estimated to be worth Rs 16,000 to Rs 22,000 crore a year.  

The rush for iron and manganese ore began in 2000 during the run up to the Beijing Olympic Games in 2008. With the price of iron ore touching $180 per tonne in the international market, Goa's mineral resources were over-exploited and even abandoned mines were reopened say activists.

Alvares says that state government claims of lacking manpower and resources to prevent illegal mining are false. The Justice M B Shah Commission, constituted to investigate mining illegalities and violation of the Forest Conservation Act and Environment (Protection) Act, inspected seven mines in Goa, last week and found all of them were operating illegally. “If the Commission, which has minimum infrastructure, can inspect mines within a week, why can't the state government do it with all the resources it has?” asks Alvares.   

Subscribe to Weekly Newsletter :

Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.

  • It is true that the mining

    It is true that the mining activity in Goa has resulted for the damage to the environment and loss of livelihoods. It is the common phenomena wherever mining activity is going on. In the process of development, mining of natural resources has to be done where they exists. There exists several policies in respect of mining starting from the stage of planning to excavation including monitoring and evaluation.

    Most of the time, the problem comes with the resettlement & rehabilitation (RR)packages. It will be good on paper and project affected people (PAPs) will not be allowed to be part of the activity of their area.

    In spite of the poor reputation on the mining activity, still it can be continued with the following measures as:

    1. The present B2B (Business to Business)should move towards B2P (Business to People).

    2. The RR packages should include the damage caused to people and environment.

    3. The PAPs should be involved at all stages starting from the stage of conceptualization to designing, implementation, monitoring and evaluation.

    4. While planning for rehabilitation, in addition to financial, land based rehabilitation should be included.

    5. All measures should be taken as mandatory for minimizing the pollution to environment i.e., in respect of air, water, soil and forests.

    6. Community Development in respect of health, education and livelihoods should be created for the PAPs and other stakeholders of the affected environment.

    7. SPCB and concerned authorities should monitor for the conditions laid in the RR.

    With all these measures, if the PAPs can participate in the whole process of mining and its allied activities and development is people driven, then, mining process can continue with out rejection from the people.

    Posted by: Anonymous | 9 years ago | Reply
  • The problems caused by mining

    The problems caused by mining in Goa are not for lack of rules and regulations and laws. The problem has been the implementation of those laws and regulations, and lack of political will to control and lack of capacity to monitor the mining operations. Another problem is that the very nature of mining operations (strip mining in Goa) means devastation and irreversible damage to the environment - there is nothing "sustainable" about demolishing entire hills and emptying water tables and silting rivers and clearing dense forest thousands and thousands of years old with important biodiversity destroyed for ever.

    If the question is livihoods for people, than the time has come for us to protetct the traditional crucial livelihhods and introduce new sustainable ways of earning a living without damaging the environment. Mining needs to be PHASED OUT in Goa immediately.

    Posted by: Anonymous | 8 years ago | Reply
  • Agree to waht you have said

    Agree to waht you have said Carme barring the last sentense.
    Regards

    Posted by: Anonymous | 7 years ago | Reply
  • A very useful and enlightening article from the author summarizing on the impact of illegal mining on the states environment and communities. I really liked the article as it has brought awareness to the society about illegal mining in Goa and its adverse effects. The article has mainly stressed on the revenue loss from illegal mining and damage it causes not only to the environment but also to the loss of livelihoods. From this article we came to know about the serious environmental problem such as deforestation, land degradation, negative effects on flora and fauna, vibration to the earth, air noise and water pollution that we are facing nowadays and it is important that government should take necessary steps to rectify this problems as soon as possible to protect our ecological system. It is sad to know that the state government allowed mining even in some forested area despite the presence of wildlife sanctuaries. The state government is not bothered to take up any action against the illegal mining in spite of having its manpower and resources. Though, mining is an industry , which is necessary to our economy as its has many advantages to the nation but it has also a cost associated with it. Mining needs to be phased out in Goa immediately. If the question is towards saving the employment of people, than the time has come for the government to introduce new sustainable ways of earning without damaging the environment.

    Posted by: Smruti Raikar | 3 years ago | Reply