pesticides have so far been touted as protectors of plants.
For the first time, a new research says some of them may actually be harming the very crops they are supposed to protect. Reason many of them cut off the communication between crops and nitrogen fixing bacteria and are a threat to natural nitrogen fixation. Result decrease in crop yields.
Researchers at the University of Oregon conducting tests on 50 pesticides found that at least 20 of them blocked connections to specific receptors inside the symbiotic rhizobium bacteria which live in the root nodules of leguminous plants in the soil, thus disrupting nitrogen fixing, the main function of such bacteria.
Legumes secrete chemical signals that attract these bacteria, which work with the plants to convert atmospheric nitrogen into ammonia, which in turn is used as fertiliser by the plants.
"In our study, the chemical component pentachlorophenol (pcp) caused the strongest inhibition for symbiotic nitrogen fixation resulting in the lowest plant yields. In addition, pcp was the only chemical that negatively affected seed germination," Jennifer Fox, the lead author of the paper told Down To Earth. pcp, which is sold as pentachlorol and chlorophen is used as insecticide, herbicide and algaecide.
She, however, stressed that none of the chemicals was toxic to either the plant or the bacteria and that pcp was unique in that it inhibited both seed germination and nitrogen fixation.
"When an overabundance of synthetic nitrogen fertiliser is applied to legume crops, the plants will produce less chemical signals to attract symbiotic rhizobia soil bacteria," Fox explained.
The scientists in their paper published online in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences on June 4, referred to two studies from 2000 that had found significant declines in both crop yield per unit of synthetic nitrogen fertiliser and a significant decline in overall symbiotic nitrogen fixation.
The most common explanation for this was the overuse of agrichemicals in legumes. This reduces the legume's natural need for nitrogen fixing.
Besides, poor soil quality due to overuse strips nutrients such as nitrogen and phosphorous, as also tillage, which interrupts root structures and disturbs bacteria when soil is turned.
"We showed that by applying pesticides that interfere with symbiotic signaling, the overall amount of symbiotic nitrogen fixation is reduced. If this natural fertiliser is not replaced by synthetic nitrogen fertilisers, crop yields go down. Or the crops need more growing time to match yields of untreated crops. This is an unforeseen contributor to declining yields," Fox said.
"This sets up a vicious cycle because the more synthetic nitrogen fertiliser we add to the soil, the less symbiotic nitrogen fixation will occur," she added. The study comes as a blow to a recent report by assocham, which had concluded that pesticides were the ultimate solution to make up annual crop losses in India.
A study by the Central Rice Research Institute at Cuttack in Orissa published in Current Science in 1980 showed that treatment of rice fields with the pesticide pyrethrin reduced nitrogen fixing ability of rice fields by 80 per cent.
Another study by Bidhan Chandra Krishi Biswavidyalaya, West Bengal, shows that population and activity of non-symbiotic bacteria are stimulated by some herbicides. "If non-symbiotic bacteria grow more, symbiotic bacteria will not have enough space to grow. This will hamper nitrogen fixation," S Malarvannan of M S Swaminathan Research Foundation said.
We are a voice to you; you have been a support to us. Together we build journalism that is independent, credible and fearless. You can further help us by making a donation. This will mean a lot for our ability to bring you news, perspectives and analysis from the ground so that we can make change together.
Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.