Governance

Why 275,000 National Health Mission workers have been protesting for 3 years

National Health Mission workers are up in arms, demanding salary and perks at par with the government's regular staff

 
By Banjot Kaur
Last Updated: Thursday 01 February 2018 | 05:37:12 AM
National Health Mission workers of Jammu and Kashmir stage protest at Srinagar, demanding regularisation of jobs (Abid Bhat)
National Health Mission workers of Jammu and Kashmir stage protest at Srinagar, demanding regularisation of jobs (Abid Bhat) National Health Mission workers of Jammu and Kashmir stage protest at Srinagar, demanding regularisation of jobs (Abid Bhat)

In 2007, when Bimla Kumari from Bihar’s Amba Kala (north) village in Piprahi block joined the National Health Mission (NHM) as an auxiliary nurse midwife (ANMs), or village-level trained health worker, on a contract basis she was determined to make the government’s “health for all” vision a reality. But a decade later, her enthusiasm has lost steam. In December 2017, she joined the state’s 16,000 NHM workers, including staff nurses, lab assistants, operation theatre technicians, pharmacists, radiographers and other peripheral health workers, who staged a week-long strike, bringing the health machinery to a halt. Her demand was regularisation of job and salary at par with the government workforce.

“Just like state cadre ANMs, I ensure primary healthcare to all the 8,000 families in my village. Every day, I walk on foot to the houses of pregnant women to ensure their well-being, counsel people on family planning and conduct routine immunisation, apart from a host of other activities, such as providing first-aid care,” she says. “But I get a meagre Rs 12,500 a month, while ANMs on government service receive Rs 40,000,” adds Kumari, who could not celebrate the New Year’s day with her family as she had to accompany an expectant mother to the hospital at the block headquarters. “Besides, I have not received salary for the past five months,” says an aggrieved Kumari.

While Kumari and other NHM workers withdrew the strike after the state government assured that a committee would be formed to look into their demands, not many are hopeful, and for a reason.

Earlier in March, the Jammu and Kashmir government had put forth such an assurance to get the striking NHM workers back to work. “The government did constitute a committee, which conceded with our demands for job regularisation and hike in salary. But its recommendations are yet to be implemented,” says Altaf Bhat, vice president of Kashmir division of J&K National Health Employees Association, adding that the 9,000 health workers have resumed strike since December 20. “We won’t go back to work until the government assures us in writing a 50 per cent hike in salary until regularisation,” adds Bhat. [The strike was on till the magazine went to print] The rage is not confined to the two sta tes. Protests by NHM workers have been reported from at least 15 states since 2015; NHM workers of several other states plan to hit the streets over the next few months.

“If contract teachers can be regularised why can’t we be?” asks Hari Raj, executive secretary of NHM workers’ association of Haryana that staged a 10 day-long protest in December. “Besides, the Supreme Court has said that equal pay for equal work principle would hold true for all temporary employees and they can claim wages at par with regularly engaged government employees holding the same post,” he adds.

Odisha NHM workers who plan to go on a strike soon have submitted a list of demands to the government. “It includes giving preference to NHM workers during recruitment of state staff, provision of career progression and a three-year contract instead of the current 11-month one,” says Dhanehwar Swain, general secretary of the state’s NHM workers association.

J Reddy, vice president of the All India NHM Workers, says, “The government should introduce human resource policy for us. Without it, we are not covered under any social security schemes like employees’ provident fund or health insurance.”

Not a small cog in the wheel

Public health experts acknowledge the role NHM health workers play in delivering care at the grassroots level. Though there is no consolidated data, they say the 275,000 NHM workers form a major chunk in the government’s health machinery. Dilip Singh Mairembam, public health expert who has worked with various UN organisations, says NHM workers have made immensely important contributions in improving critical health indicators of India. A paper by health economist Sukumar Vellakkal and published in the February 2017 issue of Health Policy and Planning states: “India’s National Rural Health Mission (NRHM), one of the largest public health programmes in the world launched in 2005, increased the uptake of institutional delivery and antenatal services, particularly among the poorest socioeconomic groups.” Experts also say NHM workers, particularly ANMs, have been instrumental in encouraging expectant mothers to avail benefits of Janani Suraksha Yojana (JSY). This has not only bettered institutional delivery rates but also had multi-factoral effects. Financial assistance from JSY led to an increase in immunisation rates, post-partum check-up rates and healthy early breastfeeding practices, says a paper by Natalie Carvalho, research fellow at the Melbourne School of Population and Global Health, published in the October 2014 issue of the Public Library of Science.

“We do agree that they must be regularised but then it is up to the states to absorb them in their cadre. The Union ministry has advised the state governments to do so,” says a senior research consultant with the National Systems of Health Resource Centre’s Human Resources for Health Team, a technical support body of the Union health ministry for NHM.

Amit Sengupta, associate global coordinator of People’s Health Movement, India, says frequent strikes by NHM workers show that they are now a demoralised workforce. “Small wonder, the Comptroller and Auditor General of India reported last year that over Rs 4,000 crore was left unspent under NRHM funds. A demoralised workforce would lead to more attrition and performance below par,” he adds.

Union Health ministry’s Rural Health Statistics 2017 show that there are 2,061 positions vacant for radiographers, 4,582 for pharmacists, 5,753 for lab technicians and 11,288 for nurses across the country. A demotivated NHM workforce would only exacerbate the situation and delay achieving the vision of NHM.

Demands they make
 
For 3 years, 275,000 National Health Mission workers have been protesting across India
  • Regularise jobs. Till then, renew contracts every five years, instead of the current 11 months
  • Payment at par with the respective workforce under the government. For instance, in Bihar, a state-cadre ANM receives Rs 40,000 a month while those under NHM get Rs 12,500
  • Introduce human resource policies for appropriate compensation and benefits. For example, women health workers in Telangana who are on payrolls of the state government get six-month maternity leave while those under NHM get none. NHM health workers claim that there is no provision for leaves other than the 12 casual leaves
  • While in most states, NHM workers demand career progression, in some they demand rollback of an annual appraisal system that requires NHM workers to score at least 60 per cent of marks. However, NHM workers claim that the appraisal is done based on the feedback of senior officials at the capital rather than their performance that remains documented at the district level. In Madhya Pradesh, 3,000 NHM workers have lost their jobs due to this provision. "The government may sack health workers if they fail to score 60 per cent for five consecutive years, and not just one year," says Rahul Jain, state-coordinator of Madhya Pradesh health workers' association
  • The government should give NHM workers preference over others while considering for vacant posts

 The article was first published in January 16-31 issue of Down To Earth under the title 'Beleagured foot soldiers'

Subscribe to Weekly Newsletter :

Related Story:

UN develops modules to provide safe work environment to health workers

Bihar faces shortage of HIV drug

Why social health activists in India live a life of uncertainty

IEP Resources:

The health system in India: the underserved majority

Estimating the cost of delivering direct nutrition interventions at scale: National and subnational level insights from India

Targeting and effects of Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana on access to care and financial protection

Debate in Lok Sabha on National Rural Health Mission and ASHA, 11/07/2014

We are a voice to you; you have been a support to us. Together we build journalism that is independent, credible and fearless. You can further help us by making a donation. This will mean a lot for our ability to bring you news, perspectives and analysis from the ground so that we can make change together.

Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.