India's population: 'Curb the number of rich children'

Reducing the population by 10% has the same effect on emissions as reducing the average consumption by 10%

By Jorgen Randers
Last Updated: Thursday 13 February 2020
Rich Indian child. Photo: iStock

I strongly favour limiting the number of children to one per woman because this will create a better world for people in the future. It is particularly important to limit the number of rich children as they have a much higher ecological footprint than poor children. The negative implications of limiting the number of children per woman will be solved if society as a whole decides to do so. 

Fertility will continue to decline in the decades ahead even if nothing extraordinary is done today to limit it, as women will voluntarily have fewer children. The likely result will be that the world population will peak to about 9 billion before 2050 and then fall to its half by 2100. It would be better if population peaks earlier and at lower levels, but that seems unlikely. As a result, there will be poverty and suffering by mid-century. 

I have changed my previous estimate about the possible catastrophe caused by overpopulation since the world has managed to reduce fertility rate dramatically — from 4.5 children per woman in the 1970s to 2.5 now. More education, health and contraception especially directed at women helped achieve this. It has dramatically improved them and made them free to be able to choose a smaller family size, though not as small as I would have wished. 

Reducing the population by 10 per cent has the same effect on emissions as reducing the average consumption by 10 per cent. I recommend the first as it would make life better for the remaining 90 per cent. It should be clear that it is more important to limit the rich population since it does much more damage per person. 

Punitive action by India will save future generations from living in an overpopulated world. China is a successful example where the one-child policy has been an essential part of the 16-doubling of the average per capita income since 1980. This success should be compared with the lacklustre performance of India in the same period. 

The author is professor emeritus, climate strategy in BI Norwegian Business School, Oslo. He co-authored the book The Limits to Growth in 1972, which predicted a catastrophe due to overpopulation in the near future

This was first published in Down To Earth's print edition (dated 1-15 February, 2020)

Subscribe to Weekly Newsletter :
Related Stories

Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.