Endgame for bustards

Great Indian Bustard has been pushed to extinction in its biggest sanctuary; breeding stops

 
By Ashwin Aghor
Last Updated: Sunday 07 June 2015

Endgame for bustards

image

Just mention the large brown-and-white bird and the residents of Mardi village in Solapur burst out in anger. The district in Maharashtra is one of the few refuges for the rare Great Indian Bustard (Ardeotis nigriceps), endemic to the grasslands of India and Pakistan. Of the 30-35 birds remaining in Maharashtra, Solapur’s grasslands support the largest population—25. But residents are not keen to protect the bird, called maldhok locally, because they perceive the Great Indian Bustard sanctuary as the stumbling block to the region’s development.

The sanctuary is spread over 8,500 sq km, spanning six talukas in Solapur and Ahmednagar districts. The irrigation department of Maharashtra is digging a canal that will bring water from Ujani dam on the Bhima river to villages in the sanctuary. The digging stopped short of the sanctuary because of its protected status. This has fuelled anger among residents. “We don’t want the bird or the sanctuary. We want the canal,” say Ramachandra Bhonsle and Santosh Kabe, residents of Mardi, which along with Nannaj village is located close to maldhok’s breeding ground. The residents want the canal water because it would allow them to grow cash crops. But the canal is a threat to the bird as it avoids irrigated areas and needs arid, semi-arid grasslands to court and nest.

Man v bird

Keeping in view the residents’ demands and the fact that parts of the sanctuary are urbanised (part of Solapur city is inside the sanctuary), the forest department has proposed reducing the sanctuary area to 1,222 sq km (one-eighth the original size) for better management. To this end, the department moved an application in the Supreme Court two months ago. “We have completed the procedure of rationalisation. The state wildlife advisory board has approved it. We are awaiting the court’s decision before proceeding further,” says M K Rao, the conservator of forests (wildlife) for the area, stationed at Pune.

image

But residents do not want any sanctuary area reduced; they want it denotified. Leaders in the area have, in fact, won elections by telling people that lives of 2.5 million people are being destroyed by 25 birds. “The birds are preventing water from coming to our fields. If the canal is completed, every farmer in the area will get sufficient water to grow cash crops like sugarcane. We demand the sanctuary be denotified as there are hardly any birds here,” says Babasaheb Awatade of the Congress party. Residents of Mardi and Nannaj strongly opposed the sanctuary during a meeting with forest officials in March.

Researchers working in Solapur say the resentment towards the bird is a recent phenomenon. “Till two years ago, people willingly gave information about sightings of birds, wolves and jackals. But ever since politicians have started criticising the sanctuary, people have backed off,” says Shivkumar More, a field researcher. More and his friend Sarang Mamane have been researching for projects on black bucks, wolves and maldhoks in Solapur since 2003. They say they have witnessed a gradual decline in the Great Indian Bustard population in the past seven years.

imageWhat is most worrying is that the bird has not bred at all in the past three years. A 100 hectare (1 sq km) grassland near Nannaj is the only existing breeding ground in the sanctuary. “The last chick was seen four years ago,” says Rajesh Hippargi, a wildlife expert in Solapur. He says the bustard disappeared from Karmala municipality bordering Ahmednagar district four or five years ago and never made a come back. “We know another Karmala-like situation is waiting to happen in Nannaj.”

The breeding ground is surrounded by private farms; cattle are let loose in the area to graze, threatening the bird’s survival. The forest department also harmed the grassland by planting glyricidia trees in mid-1970s under a drought programme. Bustards cannot survive in wooded areas. After conservationists took up the matter, the trees are now being removed. But the birds have not come back, says Hippargi.

Expert suggestions for Solapur sanctuary
 
  • Launch project bustard on the lines of Project Tiger
  • Rationalise the sanctuary limits. Exclude urbanised areas. Include patches of agricultural land contiguous to grassland
  • Use radio-telemetry and other technology to track the bird’s migratory route and explore prospective habitats
  • Establish a centre for studying grassland ecosystem and begin a captive breeding programme of the bustard near Nannaj
  • Community involvement and incentives to local residents for supporting conservation
  • Promote organic farming near sanctuaries as chemical fertilisers, pesticides and GM crops destroy insects that bustards feed on
 
The past 10 years have witnessed the greatest threat to the grassland ecosystem and the Indian bustard, he adds. The original grassland habitat in Solapur has been fragmented because of use of grasslands for agriculture and development activities. This has affected the potential of bird populations to disperse and colonise new areas.

In most bustard habitats across India, human activity is the main threat to the bird. Only an estimated 250 Great Indian Bustards survive in India. The International Union for Conservation of Nature, in its updated list of rare birds released in June, included the bird in the “critically endangered” list.

To save the breeding ground in Solapur, the forest department has proposed the acquisition of 434 hectares around Nannaj and Mardi, which is part of the rationalisation plan. The move has increased resentment among people who now fear displacement and loss of land.

What needs to be done

“Being a part of a wildlife sanctuary, people have to undergo hardships. They are against conservation of the bird because they see no incentive in it,” says Promod Patil, who runs the Great Indian Bustard Foundation in Pune. A way to involve community in protecting the bird would be to promote eco-tourism and share its benefits with people; an arrangement could be worked out wherein people are allowed to take fodder in a regulated way, says Patil. He suggests the creation of a core breeding area near Nannaj and other areas, its strict protection and management.

Experts at the Bombay Natural History Society (BNHS), who have been studying the bird for a decade, say there is an urgent need to start Project Bustard on the lines of Project Tiger, based on scientific studies and recommendations made by it. Director of BNHS, Asad Rahmani, suggests a breeding programme for the bird. “Breeding bustards is not difficult. This has been proved in the case of the Kori Bustard (native to Africa) and the Australian Bustard,” he says. Rao says launching a special programme would help the forest department undertake effective conservation programmes for the bustard”.

At the time when the Indian government was deliberating which bird to pick as the national bird, conservationists strongly pitched for the Great Indian Bustard. The peacock won the title because of its more attractive looks and the fact that the word bustard rhymes with a swear word. Will the bustard now win the battle for survival?

With inputs from Dinsa Sachan 

Gopal GavliHe gave up his farm for bustards

Farmers like Gopal Gavli are as rare in Solapur as the Great Indian Bustard. He gave up farming on 4.86 hectares (ha) of his farm in Nannaj 15 years ago. “The first pair of the Great Indian Bustard was spotted here in 1972. After reading about the bird and black bucks at the Tata institute in Osmanabad district, I decided to give my land to support the survival of the two species,” says Gavli. He farms on the remaining 1.2 ha he has. He says the forest department should encourage other farmers to do the same by offering good incentives. There was a time when farmers were willing to sell land to the forest department. “Now no one wants to cede land because of the canal,” says Gavli.

 

 

Subscribe to Weekly Newsletter :

Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.

  • Dear Ashwin, good story

    Dear Ashwin, good story indeed. Great Indian Bustard were seen in Nagpur too but neither government nor NGOs there paid attention to their presence and preserverance. Today, we do not have even one visiting Great Indian Bustard in Nagpur.
    Keep digging such stories..... Wish you all the best
    Ganesh

    Posted by: Anonymous | 9 years ago | Reply
  •  Thanks a lot sir. 

     Thanks a lot sir. 

    Posted by: Ashwin Aghor | 4 years ago | Reply
  • Dear Ashwin, Really good

    Dear Ashwin,

    Really good story and it is unbelievable action took by great man Gopal Gavali...in the era of Land fighting a common man spares his valuable land for GIB and BB..
    Salute to his greatness...and lot of thanks to him:-)

    SAVE ENVIRONMENT FOR NEXT GENERATION...

    Posted by: Anonymous | 9 years ago | Reply
  • This is a very sad situation.

    This is a very sad situation. Are we going to have to start a Project Tiger for every endangered creature on the list then? In a man versus beas situation we all know who will win. Can the birds not be relocated to areas less threatened by cultivation and human activity?

    Posted by: Anonymous | 9 years ago | Reply
  • It is really outrageous that

    It is really outrageous that the most critically endangered bird of India which is protected by law is treated in this manner by politicians from the ruling party. Greed by our politicians has already caused immense damage to our country's environment.

    Posted by: Anonymous | 8 years ago | Reply
  • now a days when we actually

    now a days when we actually started realising the value of flaura and fauna and the need to protect it , and when the project like LAVASA in Maharashtra itself has been put to hault, it is very sad that the state wildlife advisory board has approved the idea of reducing the SolapurÔÇÖs grasslands, which not only lead to the emigration of the GREAT INDIAN BUSTARD , but will also affect the other species.

    Posted by: Anonymous | 8 years ago | Reply
  • since birds are free to move

    since birds are free to move to a suitable climate and environment for briding and their survival therefore you cannot just relocate them and expect to live there, they will fly away or die one by one.
    and yes not only we need to start a project tiger, but i will suggest a better project is needed to be enforced.

    Posted by: Anonymous | 8 years ago | Reply