India has proposed approach to operationalise equity on the lines of CSE’s advocacy on the issue
Negotiations started as part of informal consultations on the issue of global stocktake, one of the key elements of the Paris Agreement.
Global Stocktake, mentioned in Article 14 of the Paris climate deal, is meant to assess collective progress of climate actions, including mitigation, adaptation and means of implementation, with a view to enhance the future round of climate action plans or Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs).
With a view to streamline negotiations, co-chairs proposed four bullet points under which discussions could take place. These relate to possible linkages and context, possible outputs, possible elements of modalities and possible elements of sources of inputs. The output of the discussions would be captured in an informal note to be prepared by co-facilitators.
Parties also emphasised on the linkages that Global Stocktake has with regard to different segments of the Paris Agreement, including long-term goals, information on NDCs, technology mechanism, transparency framework and global goal on adaptation.
Among various aspects, Parties also discussed equity as the textual language in the Paris Agreement mandates that Global Stocktake must be conducted taking equity into consideration. The issue did not seem too important for developed countries while developing countries showed keenness to discuss it.
India on stocktaking
India made a strong intervention on Global Stocktake during the informal consultations. It put forth a detailed and elaborate description of how equity can be operationalised in Global Stocktake on the lines of what Delhi-based non-profit Centre for Science and Environment has been advocating for some time now.
India said that there were different ways to operationalise equity and one approach to frame equity is in the context of the human development index (HDI).
The growth trajectory of countries has always been in relation to carbon space and the future development of countries. In terms of HDI, it will depend on the amount of carbon space. Against this backdrop, equity and Common but Differentiated Responsibilities and Respective Capabilities would be operationalised. India said that global stocktake was a comprehensive approach and should include an assessment of pre-2020 actions too.
China advocated that equity should be reflected in the synergies of different components of Global Stocktake, including means of implementation, along with mitigation and adaptation. Brazil said Equity in global stocktake should be related to fairness and ambition.
Developed countries, including the European Union, New Zealand, Japan and Canada, focused more on the modalities of global stocktake and how the process of stocktake should enhance ambition of all countries. They also stressed on how to make the process of stocktake manageable. On equity, Canada said that the “mandate is to assess collective progress, and not take stock of the goal of the Paris Agreement in terms of equity.”
Grenada was the only country that pressed for the scope of Global Stocktake to be elaborate and comprehensive to include loss and damage.
There were no concrete outcomes emerging out of discussions on global stocktake and much of the technicalities will need detailed and lengthy discussions.
Bonn climate talks begin to further implementation of Paris Agreement
Informal consultations begin on transparency framework under Paris Agreement
Bonn conference ends without making headway: CSE
Experts discuss changing landscape of finance in agriculture at Bonn talks
Ad Hoc Working Group on the Paris Agreement adopts revised agenda at the Bonn climate talks
Bonn climate talks: New funding mechanism proposed at side event to tackle energy poverty
Bonn: Developing countries push for adaptation to be included in Paris agreement
CSE calls for a global climate deal based on equity and fairness
Climate negotiators’ and scientists’ assessments of the climate negotiations
Building climate equity: creating a new approach from the ground up
The road to Paris and beyond
Draft Paris Agreement
Sunita Narain at CSE Side Event at COP17
We are a voice to you; you have been a support to us. Together we build journalism that is independent, credible and fearless. You can further help us by making a donation. This will mean a lot for our ability to bring you news, perspectives and analysis from the ground so that we can make change together.