Central Pollution Control Board says has no information on court cases for which it has to collect environmental fines
Companies that have flouted environmental norms in India have managed to evade the fines, an analysis based on the response to a Right to Information (RTI) application showed.
The fines in many cases were challenged in various courts and cases were dragged on for years, or the fines were repealed, it was found. The remaining fines were not even recovered.
The Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB), has not been able to recover a single rupee from the Coca-Cola Group, PepsiCo Group, Reliance Industries Limited, Adani Group and other big companies in the last 30 years, although there was considerable environmental pollution and damage by their operations.
Environmental fines are becoming limited to just show-cause notices and paper transactions, the assessment indicated.
Down to Earth received an RTI reply on the matter April 8, 2022 and reply to first appeal on May 12, 2022 from CPCB.
The CPCB said in its reply that they do not have a record of the environmental fines imposed till now by the Supreme Court, National Green Tribunal (NGT) and other high courts of the country from 1990-2022.
Only Rs 583 crore in environmental fines have been collected under various orders of NGT, it added.
It is shocking that the board has no information on the court cases for which it has to collect environmental fines.
At the same time, CPCB has not implemented orders for collection of fines given by the courts in various environmental cases for the last 30 years.
No penalty amount has been received from Coca-Cola Group, PepsiCo Group, Reliance Industries Limited and Adani Group under various court orders passed between 1990 and 2020, the board said in its reply.
DTE investigated some of the major court cases under which CPCB had to collect fines from these companies:
Coca-Cola: Fined Rs 50,66,31,100
A fine of close to Rs 51 crore was imposed on Coca Cola Beverages by NGT September 10, 2020 in the case of Original Application (OA) 997/2019 and 28/2020 for non-management of plastic waste under Plastic Waste Management Act (PWM), 2018.
PepsiCo India: Fined Rs 8,97,00,000
PepsiCo India was fined Rs 8 crore 97 lakh by NGT September 10, 2020 in the Original Application (OA) 997/2019 and 28/2020 for non-management of plastic waste under PWM, 2018.
Adani Group: Fined Rs 5,00,00,000
In the Jagannath Committee vs Government of India (OA 578/2018), NGT ordered the Adani Group’s Udupi Power Corporation to deposit an interim fine of Rs 5 crore to CPCB for causing pollution. The board did not receive any money from the Adani Group between 1990 and 2020, it said in its reply.
Reliance Industries: Fined Rs 79 crores
In the NGT (OA 147/2016) Aditya N Prasad vs Reliance Industries case, CPCB gave show-cause notice to Reliance with a fine of Rs 1 crore and subsequently set aside this order on February 4, 2019.
There is another case against Reliance Industries for pollution in the Singrauli area in Madhya Pradesh.
The NGT October 11, 2019 imposed a total fine of Rs 79 crore on companies operating coal mines and coal-based power plants in the severely polluted Singrauli region. The Reliance Group was also involved in this.
According to the CPCB, they have not received any amount of fine in this case as well.
We are a voice to you; you have been a support to us. Together we build journalism that is independent, credible and fearless. You can further help us by making a donation. This will mean a lot for our ability to bring you news, perspectives and analysis from the ground so that we can make change together.
Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.