Expert tracking novel coronavirus reproduction number flags surge in cases
The reproduction number (R) for the novel coronavirus disease (COVID-19) has gone up in the last one week in India, flagged an expert. That would put the R value for the country at 1.02 for February 21-23, 2021 — the first time since a surge in September 2020.
This implies that the country may see a spike in COVID-19 cases. The information was shared with Down to Earth by Sitabhra Sinha, professor at the Institute of Mathematical Sciences, Chennai, who regularly analyses these numbers for India.
The reproduction number is a measure of how contagious a disease is: It tells us the average number of people who will contract a contagious disease from one person having that disease.
If the R value is more than 1, each existing infection causes more than one new infection.
“The number for the last week was the worst I have seen since mid-September, when the R value for the country was below 1. It stayed below 1 for the entire period up till February 17,” said Sinha.
As many as seven of the 16 states with the most number of active cases have an R value greater than 1. This includes Maharashtra, which tops the list of states having the highest number of active cases. Kerala is at the second position in term of cases, but its R value has been less than 1 in the last week, according to Sinha.
The states that had an R value less than 1 are seeing a spike, with the value approaching close to 1. An increase in the number of active cases is visible, said Sinha.
The situation, however, varies within states. While both West Bengal and Tamil Nadu have an R value less than 1, cities of Kolkata and Chennai have an R value greater than 1. With this, all five major metros now have an R value greater than 1.
This increase could derail India’s fight against COVID-19 and lead to the much dreaded second wave, experts have cautioned.
“The data, field reports and test results are already indicating that we are seeing a worrying rise in the number of infections at least in some parts of the country,” said Anant Bhan, an expert on bioethics, global health and health policy based in Bhopal.
“We will need to track and see if this trend continues over the next couple of weeks. More importantly, we need to ensure that we try to control the increase fast,” he added.
|Estimated reproduction number (R) values|
|India (Estimated over February 21-23)||R: 1.02|
|R value for major urban metropolitan centers|
|Mumbai (Estimated over Feb 14-24)||
|Pune (Estimated over Feb 11-22)||R: 1.33|
|Chennai (Estimated over Feb 21-24)||R: 1.11|
|Kolkata (Estimated over Feb 17-20)||R: 1.05||No recent robust estimate of R, but data suggests R>1 at present|
|Bengaluru (Estimated over Feb 14-24)||R: 1.07|
|Delhi (Estimated over Feb 12-15)||R: 0.97||No recent robust estimate but data suggests R>1 at present|
|States with R value over 1|
|Maharashtra (Estimated over Feb 21-24)||R: 1.18|
|Karnataka (Estimated over Feb 18-21)||R: 1.07||No recent robust estimate of R, but data suggests it is still > 1|
|Punjab (Estimated over Feb 15-24)||R: 1.23|
|Chhattisgarh (Estimated over Feb 17-20)||R: 1.06||No recent robust estimate but data suggests that R<1 at present|
|Madhya Pradesh (Estimated over Feb 18-24)||R: 1.14|
|Gujarat (Estimated over Feb 21-24)||R: 1.14|
|Haryana (Estimated over Feb 20-24)||R: 1.16|
We are a voice to you; you have been a support to us. Together we build journalism that is independent, credible and fearless. You can further help us by making a donation. This will mean a lot for our ability to bring you news, perspectives and analysis from the ground so that we can make change together.
Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.