Surprisingly minor changes in the water balance are enough to explain the lake level rises, finds study
The East African Rift Valley sits between the Afar Triangle in Ethiopia and Mozambique. Within it lie a series of freshwater and alkaline lakes organised like a string of pearls.
The Kenyan lakes in the Rift have witnessed significant water level increases. Recent increases in lake areas range from 21 per cent for Lake Naivasha to 123 per cent for Solai. Homes, schools and hospitals have been flooded. A Kenyan government report estimates that about 80,000 households — 400,000 people — have been affected by the floods since 2010. There are grave economic consequences, since agricultural fields and tourism infrastructure have been damaged.
To find out what is driving the rising lake levels, my colleagues and I carried out a detailed analysis for several most affected lakes using satellite remote sensing data. We studied the changes of the lake surface areas, lake levels and water volumes, as well as the factors driving the inflows and the water balance of the lakes. These are chiefly rainfall and evaporation. Our findings provide compelling evidence that increases in rainfall since 2010 explain the lake level rises.
Human activity and changes in underground permeability have been advanced before to explain the lake level rises. The results of our study illustrate that surprisingly minor changes in the water balance are enough to explain the lake level rises. An increase of only 0.4-2 per cent of mean annual effective rainfall leads to the observed phenomena.
Three key findings / trends emerged from our data analysis:
For instance, Lake Baringo had a water area of 118km² in 1995, the lowest value in 1984 to 2020. The water area expanded by over 52 per cent in the years 2014 and 2020 to reach 195km².
The water area of Lake Solai, a smaller and less-known lake south of Lake Bogoria, increased from 3km² in 1984 to nearly 12km² in 2014 and 2020, a four-fold increase.
Significant differences between minimum and maximum water levels were found for all investigated lakes. The water level of Lake Solai increased by 8.5 metres, followed by Baringo (8.2 metres), Naivasha (7.5 metres), Nakuru (6.4 metres), Bogoria (5 metres) and Elementaita with 2.4 metres. For most lakes, the highest levels were found around 2013/2014 — until 2020, in which new record maximums were observed.
To put this into perspective, the water level rise of over 8 metres between the 1980s and 1990s for Lake Baringo and Lake Solai is equivalent to the height of around two storeys of a typical building.
2009 was a breakpoint year for lake catchment rainfall. The rainfall for the years 1981-2009 and 2010-2020 show noteworthy differences in the average annual rainfall values. This matches well with observations in lake levels, which showed low variability in water levels before 2009.
In the period 2010-2020, mean annual rainfall increased by up to 30 per cent for the Baringo, Bogoria and Solai catchments. In Nakuru (21 per cent), Elementaita (25 per cent) and Naivasha (25 per cent), the rainfall increases were somewhat lower. After 2018, annual rainfall increased by even more than 50 per cent compared to the long term averages.
Another factor driving the water balance is evapotranspiration. This is the amount of rainfall lost to the atmosphere. We found that this has also increased, though it’s not clear by how much, since no data on the ground exists to validate the findings coming from numerical simulations.
Independent of the uncertainties regarding evaporation, our results suggest that increases in rainfall most likely explain the lake level rises.
The regional climate in Eastern Africa has shown significant variability in the past, with long lasting periods of severe drought but also wetter periods as we are currently observing. Water level fluctuations in the Rift Valley lakes are not new. Lake Naivasha, for instance, was reduced to a puddle around 1850 and particularly low levels persisted throughout the 1940s and 1950s.
What is new is the immediate risk posed by rising lake levels. Compared to the past, much higher population densities around the lakes put more people, their homes and their crops in danger.
So, will the lake levels keep rising?
We don’t know. Ten thousand years ago lake levels were significantly higher. South of Lake Turkana there was a lake called Suguta which was 300 metres deep, with a surface area of around 2,150km². This is over 10 times the size of current Lake Baringo. Lakes Bogoria and Baringo were connected and drained to the north towards Suguta, which abruptly disappeared around 8,500 years ago. (There are fears the lakes may connect again, leading to a cross-contamination of alkaline and fresh water.)
There is little that humans can do to intervene, especially regarding increases in rainfall and change in climate. What we can do is to alleviate the impact and be prepared as a society. We can aim at holding back water in the catchments and upstream areas. Afforestation, implementation of soil water conservation measures and enforcing infiltration of rainfall and surface runoff by technical and natural means are beneficial. Flood protection dams may be useful in some instances: This is however very costly.
Floods are natural phenomena, which were and will always be there. Preparedness is key in flood risk management. If Kenya and other countries affected by rising lake levels cannot change the situation, the only option is to learn to deal with it.
Mathew Herrnegger, Senior Scientist, Institute of Hydrology and Water Management, University of Natural Resources and Life Science (BOKU)
We are a voice to you; you have been a support to us. Together we build journalism that is independent, credible and fearless. You can further help us by making a donation. This will mean a lot for our ability to bring you news, perspectives and analysis from the ground so that we can make change together.
Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.