Not a waste until wasted

Punjab farmers burn straw after harvest. It is time to exploit the potential of this agro-waste

By Jyotika Sood
Last Updated: Monday 17 August 2015 | 08:38:53 AM

Not a waste until wasted

Every year about 12 million tonnes of rice straw is burned in Punjab

Plumes of smoke arising from the fields is a common sight in Punjab during rice harvesting season. In the months of October-November it almost asphyxiates anyone who ventures out of house, be it a village or city. Reason: paddy stubble burning.

Burning of rice straw remains emits trace gases like carbon dioxide, meth ane, carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxide, sulphur oxide and large amount of particulate matters, which adversely affect human health as well as the environment. Last year, the magnitude of stubble burning was so high that it received international attention. The National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) released a satellite image showing large number of fires across millions of hectares of agriculture fields in Punjab.

Farmers in the state complain that rice straw is a huge problem for them because they follow mechanised agriculture. “When you harvest rice by a combine harvester, it leaves a significant length of straw on the field,” says Rajinder Kumar Sama, a farmer from Abohar district. So crop residues in combine-harvested fields are burnt. Besides, explains Sarabjit Singh from Ghanaour village in Patiala district, both wheat and rice are long-duration crops. With a short period available between rice harvesting and wheat plantation, burning is the easiest and quickest way to get rid of rice straw. Singh adds that increasing labour cost is another reason farmers prefer setting fire to their vast swathes of paddy fields after they have harvested the crop.

A 12 MW rice straw power plant requires 120,000 tonnes of stubbles a year

After China, India is the world’s largest producer of paddy. India produces 98 million tonnes of paddy with roughly 130 million tonnes of straw. Of this, about half is used as animal fodder. The rest is mostly burned in the fields, though a small amount is also consumed by brick kilns and paper and packaging industry. Despite such huge amou nts of rice straw generation, farmers in the country are yet to realise the potential of this agro-waste in terms of manure and as a profitable raw material for various industries.

Where’s the profit?

Sama says on an average one gets about two tonnes of rice straw per acre (0.4 hectare). “The combine owner or operator charges an additional Rs 850 per acre for harvesting that leftover portion which is of no use to us,” says Sama. It cannot be even fed to the cattle. Blades of fodder cutter easily get blunt by the thick and sharp straw.

Sama adds that in his area only brick kilns buy rice straw, but they are limited. Besides, selling rice straw to kilns is not profitable. “They pay us Rs 600-Rs 700 a tonne, which means we get Rs 1,200-Rs 1,400 per acre. Now subtract Rs 850 rental cost of the combine harvester and transportation cost of Rs 300, which is borne by the farmer, from the amount. All we get is between Rs 50 and Rs 250. Where is the profit?”

Daljeet Singh, another farmer from Patiala says, “Of late, power companies are approaching us to buy rice straw. They are offering between Rs 500 and Rs 700 a tonne. Last year, the paper and packaging industry had bought straw for Rs 1,400-Rs 1,700 a tonne.” That was a one-off deal though. In the absence of assured returns, farmers find stubble burning an economic way of managing the agro-waste.

Back in soil

Every year about 12 million tonnes of rice straw is burned in Punjab. Accor ding to O P Rupela, former soil microbiologist at the International Crops Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics (ICRISAT), this leads to nutrient loss from the soil which is equivalent to US $18 million worth of urea. Rupela, along with scientists from Punjab Agricultural University (PAU), has developed a simple and rapid composting technique to convert huge piles of rice straw into organically rich soil.

O P Rupela Rice straw compost can
increase crop yield by
4-9%. When applied as
mulch it helps maintain
soil fertility
O P Rupela,
former soil microbiologist, ICRISAT

It takes about 45 days to prepare this rice straw compost which helps conserve nitrogen and other nutrients contained in the straw, he says.

The compost contains 1.7 to 2.1 per cent of nitrogen, 1.5 per cent phosphorous and 1.4 to 1.6 per cent potassium. It helps improve crop yield by 4 to 9 per cent. “But the problem was that farmers found it labour-intensive,” says the soil scientist.

A PAU scientist, who does not wish to be named, agrees with Rupela. “The problem with Punjab farmers is they want quick solutions. That is why the rice straw compost was not adopted in our state as well as in neighbouring Haryana.”

Rupela offers another use of rice straw—mulching. In this method, straw is spread across the soil surface and allowed to decompose naturally into the soil by the activity of worm and other organisms. “A few farmers in Punjab have adopted it. Farmers in Andhra Pradesh, another rice growing state, have also resorted to this method as it helps maintain soil fertility,” says Rupela, adding that crops like pigeon pea, soybean and maize are easily grown even with mulch on surface.

But environment-friendly agriculture asks for extra effort and time. With farming becoming less remunerative, farmers are looking for easy and quick solutions. This is perhaps the reason burning of rice straw continues unabated across Punjab despite advisories by agricultural universities and the district administration and FIRs by agriculture officers against erring farmers.

Power industry offers a way out

For the past two years, people in villages in the radius of 25 kilometres around Ghanaour village of Patiala are witnessing relief from choking air during harvesting seasons. Complaints of respiratory problems have also reduced. This is attributed to hundreds of farmers who decided to sell their rice straw to a power company, Punjab Biomass Power Ltd (PBPL) in Ghanaour.

imageThe company’s agents had approa ched the farmers to harvest the straw for a dividend in cash. The proposal was luring enough, but farmers had strict time constraints.

The company offered its own machinery to harvest and collect straw on time so that farmers do not get delayed for the next crop. Farmers agreed. Last year PBPL generated 12 MW while helping farmers reduce the pollution levels considerably (see box).

S Y Mehta, plant head of PBPL, says, “A 12 MW rice-straw power plant typically needs 120,000 tonnes of stubble, which can be collected from about 15,000 farmers.”

Power sector pundits say that energy demand may increase by 50 per cent by 2030 and, as Mehta says, power production from rice straw is a promising way to meet the demand. If enough biomass power plants are set up, it will provide a new source of income to farmers, he adds.

S Y Mehta We pay Rs 900 a tonne for non-basmati rice straw and Rs 1,500 for basmati rice straw
S Y Mehta, head,
Punjab Biomass Power Ltd

But the power industry pays less to farmers than the packaging industry. Mehta says paper and packaging industry needs straw in small amounts and hence are spoiling the market (see ‘What industry pays’). “Our straw requirement is 350 to 400 tonnes a day. We pay about Rs 900 a tonne for non-basmati rice straw and Rs 1,500 for basmati straw as it has high calorific value,” Mehta says, adding that prices may increase in the future as the market becomes competitive. Mehta hopes that PBPL, which is currently incurring losses, will be able to make profits in two to three years.

With several applications, increasing demand and competitive prices, it seems farmers have no dearth of options for managing the agro-waste in a profitable way. Howe ver, convincing them about economic viability of the options could be a challenge.

Rupela says farmers will give up burning rice straw only if they receive a lucrative incentive. For this he has a suggestion: policy makers can devise a plan to offer incentives to farmers to stop the polluting stubble burning and later credit the incentives through international carbon trading.

Rice straw to power ...
Punjab Biomass Power Ltd is the first of the nine rice straw power plants coming up in Punjab. This 12 MW plant near Ghanaur village in Patiala district is functioning for the past one year. It uses rice straw (not husk that is widely used as an expensive commercial fuel) for producing power. Every day the plant consumes 350 to 400 tonnes of straw and produces 40 to 50 tonnes of ash.

Agents appointed by the company approach farmers to harvest their rice straw. The harvesting is followed by cutting, baling and transporting the bales to company depots where it is stored. The plant, set up at the cost of Rs 80 crore, is based on the simple principle of combustion. It has a furnace, a boiler and a steam turbine. There are also a set of machines that cut open the bales and shred the straw into small pieces to ensure uniform combustion. The shredded straw is then fed into the boiler using a conveyor belt. A conventional steam turbine then generates electricity. An electrostatic precipitator to collect ash ensures minimal atmospheric pollution. Although there will be some emissions from combustion, the project is eco-friendly and aims to earn substantial carbon credits.

What about the ash produced by the plant every day? S Y Mehta, head of Punjab Biomass Power Limited (PBPL), says we are trying our best to find ways of utilising the ash by selling it for production of bricks and other construction materials. For the time being a contractor has been hired who dumps the ash in landfills or depressions created at brick kilns.

Apart from combustion, Mehta informs, there are other technologies to produce power from rice straw, such as anaerobic digestion (biogas), pyrolysis (bio-oil) and gasification (sygas). The last two are under research and development as they are not economically viable, Mehta adds. PBPL has signed an MoU with the Punjab State Power Corporation for selling electricity at Rs 5.18 per unit. The other rice straw plants which are in the inception stage will supply electricity at Rs 5.83 per unit. PBPL now plans to introduce a rice straw power plant in Bihar.

... and to compost

Take dry rice straw bundled in sizes of 5 to 10 kg and soak them in solution prepared by mixing one milliliter of fungal (Aspergillus awamori) spore suspension and one gramme of urea with water for every one litre of solution. The dry straw bundle will soak up to one-and-a-half times its weight of the solution. For instance, a 5 kg bundle will use up 7.5 to 8 litres of the solution. The wet straw bundle is then drained over a polythene sheet spread over a sloping surface for about 20 minutes. The drained solution can be re-collected and re-used.

The well-drained bundles are then sprinkled with powdered rock phosphate and placed layer by layer over dried twigs to form a heap. The gap between soil and the straw bundles will help in aeration. The heap should be ideally 1.5 metre high and wide, and 5 metres long. Such a heap is likely to accommodate 500 kg of straw soaked in 750 litres of solution. The heap is then covered with a layer of dry straw to ensure moisture retention in the heap.

The heap now needs water supply at regular intervals. For this, an injection-pipe is designed, which is thrust into the heap and delivers 10 to 40 litres of water a minute. The first watering of 100 litres is done on the seventh day. Then the heap is turned well on the 15th day and 240 litres of water is poured into it. On the 30th day, the heap is turned again and 200 litres of water is added. Following these procedures, the temperature at the centre of the heap reaches 60oC within four days, while temperature at the base of the heap remains 4oC to 6oC. The heap will be composted by the 45th day, which is indicated by dark colouration and sweet earthy smell of the heap. Though straw strands will be visible, they will break easily. The soft compost is ready.


Subscribe to Weekly Newsletter :

Related Story:

NASA draws attention to fires in Punjab fields

Stubble trouble

We are a voice to you; you have been a support to us. Together we build journalism that is independent, credible and fearless. You can further help us by making a donation. This will mean a lot for our ability to bring you news, perspectives and analysis from the ground so that we can make change together.

Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.

  • Hello,
    I currently live in the outskirts of Bilaspur (Chhatisgarh), India. There nearby lands are either under the industrial sector or agriculture. Here, the farmers do a LOT of stubble burning, it's plain in sight and the amount of fly ash coming into our homes is a bit overwhelming. I wanted to know if there is an NGO / non-NGO office or firm i can contact, for them to teach the farmers the potential of the stubble they are burning to convert the same into compost.
    At home, i do my bit and convert all the vegetable waste and any biodegradable waste into compost via my compost maker (in 60 days), the only garbage exiting the house are plastic wrappers.
    I really wish there was some way for the local farmers here to get educated to stop stubble farming. Any help or suggestion would really help me. Thanks a lot!!!

    Posted by: Tanushree | 8 months ago | Reply