Lawsuit over bike lane in New York

Most say it calms traffic, some claim threatens pedestrians’ safety
Lawsuit over bike lane in New York
Published on

A DISPUTE has erupted on the streets of New York. It is about the streets themselves. Bike lanes, to be precise.

A bike lane was installed in Brook-lyn area on residents’ request in 2010. But on March 7 this year a section of the residents filed a lawsuit in a city court against the city’s transport department and its commissioner Janette Sadik-Khan, seeking removal of the lane installed along the street Prospect Park West. They say shortfalls in design of the two-way lane put pedestrians and bikers at constant risk of collision.

BEFORE
 
  • Three lanes for motor vehicles
  • One-way motor traffic
  • No road space for bikes
  • Bicyclists encroached footpaths
AFTER
 
  • Two lanes for motor vehicles
  • One-way motor traffic
  • Two-way bike lane on one side
  • Bike lane flanked by a buffer zone
 
Eric McClure, campaign coordinator for Park Slope Neighbors in New York, talks to Arushi Mittal on the controversial bike lane installed in Brooklyn area

How did the bike lane project start?

We called for the redesign of Prospect Park West in February 2009 to calm traffic in the street. A campaign was launched in which 1,300 people signed a petition asking the city’s transport department to replace one of the three lanes from the street with a protected two-way bike path. Community Board 6 endorsed the project and it was implemented in July 2010.

How valid are the allegations in the lawsuit?

The lawsuit has no merit. Facts do not support the allegations made in the lawsuit, and the alleged "compromises" they have put forth could put people at risk. The transport department has done sufficient community outreach, data collection and reporting for this project.

What are the repercussions of the lawsuit?

The lawsuit has fuelled a media bias against cycling. People opposing the bike lane are trying to show that something untoward is happening between officials of the transport department and bike proponents. On the other hand, the frivolousness of the lawsuit has also encouraged some people who were earlier not actively involved in the campaign to rally to the cause.

What is the motivation behind this lawsuit?

It represents an unwillingness to accept change. It is very clear that the people most vehemently opposed the bike path object because of the aesthetic change to Prospect Park West. I'm convinced they will eventually get used to it. 

Related Stories

No stories found.
Down To Earth
www.downtoearth.org.in