Bhopal : A Toxic Legacy

Published on:

19 Jun 2010, 10:21 am

<p>350 tonnes of toxic waste is still lying inside the factory. The broken roof of the shed allows rain to wash away the chemicals that seep underground. Since 2005, the Madhya Pradesh High Court has issued various directions for the removal of the waste. It had asked for the incinerable waste to be sent to a private facility in Gujarat. The facility refused the waste following the furore raised by activists. Groundwater continues to test positive for pesticides in and around the factory<br /><br /><br /><br />Photographs by: Sayantan Bera</p>

350 tonnes of toxic waste is still lying inside the factory. The broken roof of the shed allows rain to wash away the chemicals that seep underground. Since 2005, the Madhya Pradesh High Court has issued various directions for the removal of the waste. It had asked for the incinerable waste to be sent to a private facility in Gujarat. The facility refused the waste following the furore raised by activists. Groundwater continues to test positive for pesticides in and around the factory

Photographs by: Sayantan Bera

<p>The solar evaporation pond behind the UCIL plant was used to dump the factory’s chemical waste. Its plastic lining is torn and the waste is piled on the sides. In 2007, the state government studied the health of 24-year-olds near the pond. It found high morbidity among them compared to those living elsewhere in Bhopal. The study attributed the high incidence to poor water quality and socio-economic standards<br /><br /><br /><br />Photographs by: Sayantan Be</p>

The solar evaporation pond behind the UCIL plant was used to dump the factory’s chemical waste. Its plastic lining is torn and the waste is piled on the sides. In 2007, the state government studied the health of 24-year-olds near the pond. It found high morbidity among them compared to those living elsewhere in Bhopal. The study attributed the high incidence to poor water quality and socio-economic standards

Photographs by: Sayantan Be

<p>Ailments of the eyes and lungs are common among the residents of old Bhopal who visit government hospitals<br /><br /><br /><br />Photographs by: Sayantan Bera</p>

Ailments of the eyes and lungs are common among the residents of old Bhopal who visit government hospitals

Photographs by: Sayantan Bera

<p>In 1994, hospitals in Bhopal were full of young victims of the gas even though they were not born at the time of the accident. Several of them receiving treatment in clinics and super specialty hospitals opened after the disaster, ran out of the compensation money before finishing the course of treatment <br /><br /><br /><br />Photographs by: Arvind Yadav</p>

In 1994, hospitals in Bhopal were full of young victims of the gas even though they were not born at the time of the accident. Several of them receiving treatment in clinics and super specialty hospitals opened after the disaster, ran out of the compensation money before finishing the course of treatment

Photographs by: Arvind Yadav

<p>Every day The Dow Chemical Company receives calls from protesters asking it to dispose of chemicals lying at the factory. Sixteen years after the disaster, Dow took over Union Carbide and became the world’s second largest chemical company. It inherits assets and liabilities of Union Carbide<br /><br /><br /><br />Photographs by: Surya Sen</p>

Every day The Dow Chemical Company receives calls from protesters asking it to dispose of chemicals lying at the factory. Sixteen years after the disaster, Dow took over Union Carbide and became the world’s second largest chemical company. It inherits assets and liabilities of Union Carbide

Photographs by: Surya Sen

<p>An afternoon in Jai Prakash Nagar. People living around the UCIL plant suffer from chronic ailments and abnormalities. Residents claim children can’t run 100 metres without falling short of breath. No one knows whether these are the fallouts of the gas leak or the continued exposure to toxins. A long-term epidemiological research by Indian Council of Medical Research was terminated in 1994 and the Madhya Pradesh study is poor and disputed<br /><br /><br /><br />Photographs by: Surya Sen</p>

An afternoon in Jai Prakash Nagar. People living around the UCIL plant suffer from chronic ailments and abnormalities. Residents claim children can’t run 100 metres without falling short of breath. No one knows whether these are the fallouts of the gas leak or the continued exposure to toxins. A long-term epidemiological research by Indian Council of Medical Research was terminated in 1994 and the Madhya Pradesh study is poor and disputed

Photographs by: Surya Sen

<p>Manoj Panthi once fell unconscious inside a factory tank while cleaning it. “The mask did not help,” said Panthi. He was hired by contractors for Rs 40 a day to scrap chemicals off tanks that once contained methyl isocyanate and to mix lime with the chemicals and stack the solid waste in sacks. “We were about 15 people. Our eyes would itch. Two of my friends passed away within a year of working there.” <br /><br /><br /><br />Photographs by: Sayantan Bera</p>

Manoj Panthi once fell unconscious inside a factory tank while cleaning it. “The mask did not help,” said Panthi. He was hired by contractors for Rs 40 a day to scrap chemicals off tanks that once contained methyl isocyanate and to mix lime with the chemicals and stack the solid waste in sacks. “We were about 15 people. Our eyes would itch. Two of my friends passed away within a year of working there.”

Photographs by: Sayantan Bera

<p>Security personnel were deployed at the factory in 1994 to prevent people from putting up tombstones commemorating the Bhopal victims. Three thousand people died on the day of the leak. Many more succumbed over the years<br /><br /><br /><br />Photographs by: Pradip Saha</p>

Security personnel were deployed at the factory in 1994 to prevent people from putting up tombstones commemorating the Bhopal victims. Three thousand people died on the day of the leak. Many more succumbed over the years

Photographs by: Pradip Saha

<p>Over the years the concerns of Bhopal residents have shifted from compensation and hospitals to the clean-up of the pesticide factory. Complaints of headache and stomachache are common among them<br /><br /><br /><br />Photographs by: Surya Sen</p>

Over the years the concerns of Bhopal residents have shifted from compensation and hospitals to the clean-up of the pesticide factory. Complaints of headache and stomachache are common among them

Photographs by: Surya Sen

<p>Eight years ago Dinesh Panthi’s legs started failing him. He has since been taking painkillers and is unable to work. He was compensated for the death of his father and sister but not for himself. Of the settlement money Union Carbide India Limited (UCIL) paid, Rs 1,300 crore is still lying with the Central government. Panthi received one lakh rupees for the loss of two relatives when the compensation in case of each death was fixed at one lakh rupees <br /><br /><br /><br />Photographs by: Sayantan Bera</p>

Eight years ago Dinesh Panthi’s legs started failing him. He has since been taking painkillers and is unable to work. He was compensated for the death of his father and sister but not for himself. Of the settlement money Union Carbide India Limited (UCIL) paid, Rs 1,300 crore is still lying with the Central government. Panthi received one lakh rupees for the loss of two relatives when the compensation in case of each death was fixed at one lakh rupees

Photographs by: Sayantan Bera

<p>The scale of toxins spread cannot be attributed to the gas leak alone. It betrays mismanagement of chemicals in India. About 32,000 chemicals are produced in the country; the composition of only 3,000 is known and the long-term effects of fewer on health and the environment. With the law providing no deterrence and an unaccountable corporate, a Bhopal is waiting to happen at the turn of every street<br /><br /><br /><br />Photographs by: Sayantan Bera</p>

The scale of toxins spread cannot be attributed to the gas leak alone. It betrays mismanagement of chemicals in India. About 32,000 chemicals are produced in the country; the composition of only 3,000 is known and the long-term effects of fewer on health and the environment. With the law providing no deterrence and an unaccountable corporate, a Bhopal is waiting to happen at the turn of every street

Photographs by: Sayantan Bera

<p>Protests across Bhopal against Union Carbide marked the 10th anniversary of the gas tragedy. Little has changed since, except that more patients are visiting hospitals. The waste is still lying in the factory, poisoning the soil and water. Treatment is difficult because the company refuses to divulge the composition of the chemicals used in the pesticide factory. In 1991, the Supreme Court reinstated criminal proceedings against Union Carbide<br /><br /><br /><br />Photographs by: Pradip Saha</p>

Protests across Bhopal against Union Carbide marked the 10th anniversary of the gas tragedy. Little has changed since, except that more patients are visiting hospitals. The waste is still lying in the factory, poisoning the soil and water. Treatment is difficult because the company refuses to divulge the composition of the chemicals used in the pesticide factory. In 1991, the Supreme Court reinstated criminal proceedings against Union Carbide

Photographs by: Pradip Saha

<p>Patients await their turn outside a clinic. Business has been booming for the 275 private clinics and practitioners in the city. People identified as affected by the gas leak were given smart cards to facilitate treatment. The cards made it easy to identify them and paying customers were given preference<br /><br /><br /><br />Photographs by: Surya Sen<br /><br /> </p>

Patients await their turn outside a clinic. Business has been booming for the 275 private clinics and practitioners in the city. People identified as affected by the gas leak were given smart cards to facilitate treatment. The cards made it easy to identify them and paying customers were given preference

Photographs by: Surya Sen

<p>Nav Jeevan colony in old Bhopal receives municipal water once in every two days. In 1994, the Supreme Court monitoring committee on hazardous waste reported groundwater contamination near the factory. The court ordered clean water be supplied to the residents. It was only after two marches – from Bhopal to Delhi in 2006 and 2008 – by residents that a pipeline was laid. But the supply is erratic, so people continue to depend on groundwater <br /><br /><br /><br />Photographs by: Sayantan Bera</p>

Nav Jeevan colony in old Bhopal receives municipal water once in every two days. In 1994, the Supreme Court monitoring committee on hazardous waste reported groundwater contamination near the factory. The court ordered clean water be supplied to the residents. It was only after two marches – from Bhopal to Delhi in 2006 and 2008 – by residents that a pipeline was laid. But the supply is erratic, so people continue to depend on groundwater

Photographs by: Sayantan Bera

The Madhya Pradesh government wants to open the Union Carbide plant to the public. The principal secretary of the state claims this will dispel the “myth” about toxins left at the site. A recent study by Centre for Science and Environment found that the profile of chemicals found within the factory premises matches that of chemicals found in adjacent localities. Moderately persistent chemicals called Carbamates were also found in the city’s groundwater. Clearly, the factory is polluting the environment even 25 years after the plant was shut down

<p>Bhopal residents affected by the gas leak had to wait for hours before they could reach the counters of the courts for compensation claim. Those who were too ill to stand in the queue could not register claims. The Indian government sued Union Carbide for $3.3 billion but in 1989 settled for $470 million on the Supreme Court’s direction<br /><br /><br /><br />Photographs by: Pradip Saha</p>

Bhopal residents affected by the gas leak had to wait for hours before they could reach the counters of the courts for compensation claim. Those who were too ill to stand in the queue could not register claims. The Indian government sued Union Carbide for $3.3 billion but in 1989 settled for $470 million on the Supreme Court’s direction

Photographs by: Pradip Saha

<p>He guarded the Bhopal factory in 2004 and would complain of a persistent headache. Dow refuses to treat the hazardous waste lying at Union Carbide India Ltd (UCIL). Union Carbide Corporation began selling its stakes in its Indian branch, UCIL, in 1994<br /><br /><br /><br />Photographs by: Surya Sen</p>

He guarded the Bhopal factory in 2004 and would complain of a persistent headache. Dow refuses to treat the hazardous waste lying at Union Carbide India Ltd (UCIL). Union Carbide Corporation began selling its stakes in its Indian branch, UCIL, in 1994

Photographs by: Surya Sen

Industry

Pesticide Industry

news

CSE Study