- If you are not yet a Down To Earth subscriber, please click here to subscribe: Subscription
- If you are an existing Down To Earth subscriber, please log in to download digital archives.
The settlement is historic as families of 591 workers have opted for an ex-gratia payment by the company for all that they endured while getting exposed to toxic mercury
After a sustained campaign of 15 years, Hindustan Unilever Limited (HUL), a subsidiary of UK-based Unilever, finally entered into a settlement to provide “undisclosed” ex-gratia amount to the victims of mercury contamination from its unit in Kodaikanal, Tamil Nadu. The settlement has been considered as success of a first ever litigation in India moved by industrial workers against exposure to toxic chemicals. A similar class action moved by the employees for damages before the High Court of London since the company is headquartered in United Kingdom will also be withdrawn in view of the settlement, according to the legal counsel of the employees, R Vaigai.
The ongoing court battle between the workers, Tamil Nadu state government and HUL was supposed to be heard on Wednesday, when legal counsel of both the parties informed a Madras High Court bench that an agreement was reached between the two parties. In 2006, Ponds Hindustan Lever Limited Ex-Mercury Employees Welfare Association filed a writ petition against Hindustan Unilever Limited (then Hindustan Lever Limited), the Union of India and the State of Tamil Nadu.
The Madras High Court agreed HUL’s demand to not disclose the ex-gratia amount to be provided to the workers. “We are under the court’s orders not to disclose the ex-gratia amount since workers agreed to the confidentiality clause,” added Vaigai. Workers however seem to be satisfied with the decision. S A Mahindra Babu, the president of the Pond’s HLL ex-Mercury Employees Welfare Association said, “We are pleased with all the terms of the agreement which will help to ensure the long-term health and well-being of the factory’s former workers. We now consider this issue to be fully resolved and have no more grievance against the company in this regard.”
On the other hand, Dev Bajpai, Executive Director (Legal and Corporate affairs) HUL said that in the last two years company had meetings with stakeholders to resolve the issue. He asserted that “the wellbeing of our employees and the communities in which we operate has and will always remain paramount.”
Vangai, representing the workers, approached the Madras High Court and invoked Article 21, seeking the Central and the state governments to protect the life and personal liberty of the workers. “However we have not moved a plea for compensation/ damages,” she added.
In the writ petition these employees of HUL’s thermometer factory at Kodaikanal alleged that they were
The former employees’ association also wanted the court to prosecute HUL for violation of provisions of Factories Act, 1948 and Water and Environment Act. They further wanted the Central government to revise the occupational health and safety standards with reference to mercury exposure in the Factories Act and compensation in Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923. The high court bench appointed advocate Suhrith Parthasarathy as nodal commissioner to implement the settlement and posted the matter to March 28 for reporting compliance.
In 2001, the mercury thermometer factory operated by HUL in Kodaikanal was shut down by state pollution control board after the company was caught for dumping toxic mercury wastes in a densely populated part of town. By the company's own admissions, more than two tonnes of mercury have been discharged into Kodaikanal's environment. A 2011 Government of India study on workers' health concluded that many workers suffered from illnesses caused by workplace exposure to mercury.
On the larger question of environmental damage caused by HUL, activists are saying that they have just won half the battle. “The much-delayed settlement is great news, but Unilever still has unfinished business in Kodaikanal. You can expect a high-decibel global campaign in the coming months to ensure that Unilever cleans up its mercury contaminated site in Kodaikanal to international standards,” said Nityanand Jayaraman, a Chennai-based writer and activist who has been part of the campaign since 2001. HUL, according to the activist, is still insisting on leaving up to 25 milligrams/kg of mercury in soil—250 times higher than naturally occurring background levels—even after clean-up. According to activists, that is far laxer than global standards and will harm the environment. The factory is located on a ridge surrounded by the densely forested Kodaikanal Wildlife Sanctuary.
In the United Kingdom, where Unilever is headquartered, even residential standard for mercury in soil is 1 mg/kg – 25 times stricter than what HUL is proposing for an eco-sensitive area in India. Environmental organisations such as The Other Media have declared that they will build pressure on Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board (TNPCB) and HUL to commit to a world class clean-up in the coming months.
Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.