Bt brinjal set for field trial, experts warn of health risks
with the green light from the Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (geac), Bt brinjal -- a genetically modified (gm) food crop developed by the seed company Mahyco -- is ready for large-scale field trials and seed production. But the clearance is facing stiff resistance from farmers, environmentalists, and consumer groups across the country, who fear that gm food crops have major health risks.
Of the three gm food crops in India -- brinjal, mustard and potato -- awaiting permission for large-scale field trials and seed production, brinjal is the first one to get geac approval. Bt cotton is the only other gm crop permitted in the country. Mahyco has sought permission for four Bt brinjal hybrids: mhb-4 Bt, mhb 9 Bt, mhb 80 Bt and mhbj -99 Bt, containing the Cry 1 Ac genetic sequence. " The hybrids have successfully completed biosafety trials," says M K Khan, secretary, department of biotechnology, Union ministry of science and technology .
A coalition of anti- gm groups has produced evidence and scientific validations suggesting potential health hazards relating to Bt brinjal. "We need to be extra cautious before going for such large-scale trials of gm food crops," says Rajesh Krishnan of Greenpeace. "Cry 1 Ac, the Bt toxin used in Bt brinjal, is a powerful immunising agent and actively binds to gut cells of mammals," says Kavitha Kuruganthi, spokesperson of the coalition. "While Cry toxins are known allergens, two other genes -- the aad marker and the npt-ii marker gene -- used in Bt brinjal are antibiotic-resistant. Besides, the cauliflower mosaic virus, used as a promoter (used to activate the Bt gene) in Bt brinjal, is also known to initiate transcriptional activity in human cells," she adds. There are fears that the promoter might reactivate dormant viruses and raise health concerns like cancer.
geac has taken notice of allegations raised by anti- gm groups and asked Mahyco to clarify certain safety concerns. The company is yet to come up with a proper explanation. But Mahyco refutes this. "Toxicological, nutritional and allergenicity studies in public sector institutions have found Bt brinjal absolutely safe. Studies also inform that when cooked the Cry 1 Ac protein degenerates rapidly making it safe for human consumption," says Sanjay Deshpande, spokesperson of Mahyco.
Bt brinjal has been developed in collaboration with a number of public sector institutions like the Indian Institute of Vegetable Research, Varanasi, Tamil Nadu Agriculture University, Coimbatore, University of Agricultural Sciences, Dharwad, Cornell University, usa, and the University of Philippines. "The genetic transformation in brinjal was achieved in 2000 and its biosafety was established by rigorous scientific studies and trials for more than five years," says Deshpande.
Bt brinjal, with its pest resistance capacity, will drastically bring down crop loss and thereby increase the brinjal yield in the country by 54 to 113 per cent, claims Mahyco.
We are a voice to you; you have been a support to us. Together we build journalism that is independent, credible and fearless. You can further help us by making a donation. This will mean a lot for our ability to bring you news, perspectives and analysis from the ground so that we can make change together.
Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.