The poorest shun MGNREGA

Participation of Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes in the scheme has halved in five years

 
By Jitendra
Last Updated: Monday 17 August 2015

The poorest shun MGNREGA

image

imageThe Centre’s flagship rural employment guarantee scheme seems to be losing appeal for its target groups. An analysis of the monitoring report of the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) by Down To Earth (DTE) shows participation of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in the scheme has more than halved in last five years.

The scheme, hyped as one of the key development interventions of the government, guarantees 100 days of manual employment a year to a rural household that demands work. Since its inception, its hallmark has been the wide participation of casual workers belonging to SC/ST communities.

In 2008-09, about 55 per cent of those employed under MGNREGA were SC/ST. But over the period their percentage of participation in the scheme as well as the number of days for which they are provided employment has decreased. The decline was steep in last two years (see graphs).

In 2008-09, STs accounted for close to 26 per cent of the total labour participation in MGNREGA. Their participation was barely 16 per cent by the end of 2012. The participation of SC people came down from 29 to 22 per cent during the period. The decline was about 50 per cent in Bihar, Gujarat, Uttar Pradesh, Tamil Nadu and Maharashtra that have high concentration of SC people.

Government clueless

Officials in charge of the scheme both at the centre and states are unable to explain the trend. D k jain, in-charge of MGNREGA at the ministry of rural development, says, “it’s a new and surprising trend for us. It would be prudent to comment after doing an in-depth study of the trend.” Ravindra pastor, commissioner in-charge of MGNREGA in madhya pradesh, considers the trend as a sign of development.

“under MGNREGA, people have created a large number of assets, especially dug wells. This has improved irrigation and encouraged them to work in their fields rather than working in the scheme,” pastor adds. Madhya pradesh has witnessed the steepest decline in st participation. Their person-days of labour has shrunk from 138 million to 21 million between 2008-09 and 2012.

Karnataka and Chhattisgarh are two other states where the participation of STs in the scheme has declined significantly. When contacted, commissioner in-charge of MGNREGA in the states denied the trend.

DTE spoke to several analysts of the MGNREGA programme. Though unable to specify the reason, most of them blamed the decline on the delay in wage payment. Another reason is, says Abhay Kumar Pandey, director of Social Audit department, the scheme has given people the bargaining power to get jobs elsewhere. The department was created last year to audit MGNREGA.

Nikhil Dey of Mazdoor Kishan Shakti Sangthan of Rajasthan says the overall demand for work under MGNREGA is declining. He blames it on delay in payments and corruption. Bastar-based activist Shashikant says the declining trend could be because most people in the hinterlands are not aware that it is their right to demand work under MGNREGA.

Andhra Pradesh that has witnessed moderate increase in SC/ST participation, however, indicates the probable reason. V Karuna, director of MGNREGA, says, “We are trying to transform this supply-driven scheme into a demand-driven one. We manage everything, from jobs’ application to transaction of money to beneficiaries, electronically. This has brought transparency into the system.” This has instilled confidence in the poorest that MGNREGA offers assured work.

DTE’s analysis result does not augur well for the ruling United Progressive Alliance (UPA) at the Centre as it gears up for the 2014 general elections. MGNREGA is believed to be the main reason for UPA’s return to power in the 2009 general elections.

Subscribe to Weekly Newsletter :
Related Stories

Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.

  • The analysis of the fact is

    The analysis of the fact is little worrying. Why this is happening? Has anyone conducted study, actually met people belonging to SC/ST households? If they have found better options due to increased negotiation power, that is good. But I wonder whether this would have really happened. MGNREGA is not only about 'wages' but also about 'rights of a wage worker'. Look forward to the analysis of causes leading to this situation.

    Posted by: Anonymous | 7 years ago | Reply
  • In Hindi, MGNREGA is

    In Hindi, MGNREGA is pronounced as 'man-re- ga' (according to own will), by common folk. The scheme was a good initiative of UPA-I government but met the same fate as other schemes. It was a game-changer for UPA-I and brought it a second term as UPA II. In this story, Mr. Ravindra Pastor, commissioner in-charge of MGNREGA in Madhya Pradesh, version is quite noticeable as well as debatable. He was reasoning out the reason but failed. Actually, he is joking. His version is full of tricks. Mr Pastor is the kind of bureaucrat who can turn around the important subject as laughing stock which erodes seriousness of the subject.
    This story is showing government is careless about the schemes for the poor. It is an appreciative effort of the reporter.

    Posted by: Anonymous | 7 years ago | Reply
  • Did this reporter go to the

    Did this reporter go to the houses of sc/st's and saw what the officials saying is indeed true(the assets)? I don't think so. They must have been marginalized in this case too by the other sections of people and officials working together. This should be checked.

    Posted by: Anonymous | 7 years ago | Reply