- If you are not yet a Down To Earth subscriber, please click here to subscribe: Subscription
- If you are an existing Down To Earth subscriber, please log in to download digital archives.
Environment ministry sides with Odisha government, ignores people’s forest rights
THE Union Ministry of Environment and Forests, or MoEF, has given final clearance to the POSCO steel project in Odisha. While doing so, it ignored the forest rights claims of people living in the project site in Jagatsinghpur district. The gram sabhas of two of the seven affected villages—Dhinkia and Gobindpur—had written to the ministry on March 10 about their resolution not to part with their land for the project unless the process of recognising their rights over the forestland is completed.
They relied on the Forest Rights Act (FRA) of 2006, which recognises the rights of forest dwellers over forests and its resources, and says such people cannot be evicted unless the process of recognition of rights is completed. The ministry’s own order of July 2009 makes it mandatory for state governments to furnish affidavits from the gram sabhas of affected villages giving consent to the project and certifying that the FRA process has been completed.
But MoEF chose to go along with the claim of the state government that there are no forest dwellers eligible for forest rights at the project site and that the resolutions passed by the two gram sabhas are “invalid and fraudulent”. On May 2, MoEF gave the Odisha government permission to divert 1,253 hectares (ha) of forestland for the project proposed by the South Korean steel giant, Pohang Iron and Steel Company (POSCO).
Union Minister of State for Environment and Forests Jairam Ramesh justified his decision saying the “implementation of both FRA and the July 2009 order is a learning and evolving process since we are still in largely uncharted territory”. He said the decision will not “weaken” the implementation of FRA.
The steel plant was initially given forest clearance in 2009 on the condition that rights under FRA would be settled. Odisha government circumvented the condition by claiming there were no forest dwellers at the project site who are eligible for forest titles under FRA.
The state government’s claim was proven a lie when a sub-committee of the National Forest Rights Act Committee, set up by MoEF and the Union tribal affairs ministry, submitted documentary evidence showing the presence of traditional forest dwellers at site. Later, another committee of MoEF, constituted to inquire into the issues related to POSCO, confirmed these findings.
Last November, the Forest Advisory Committee of MoEF recommended temporary withdrawal of forest clearance to the project. But this did not stall the project. On January 31, MoEF said the state could proceed with the project if it gives an undertaking that there are no legally tenable claims of forest dwellers in the project site (see ‘POSCO gets green signal’, Down To Earth, February 28, 2011). But uncertainty over clearance to the project continued when Dhinkia and Gobindpur sent their gram sabha resolutions. These were brought to the notice of MoEF by the POSCO Pratoridh Sangram Samiti (PPSS), a people’s forum spearheading the anti-POSCO movement.
When the two resolutions were referred to the Odisha government, it said the resolutions were passed without the necessary quorum and therefore invalid. Under FRA, the gram sabha meeting for passing a resolution should be attended by at least two-thirds of a village’s adult population. In Dhinkia only 69 of the total 3,445 adult voters signed the resolution; in Gobindpur only 64 of the 1,904 voters signed it, the state government said. It also said the gram sabhas have to be convened by the gram panchayats and resolutions should have been recorded in the format prescribed by the Odisha Gram Panchayat Rules of 1964; these procedures were not followed. Rather, the sarpanch (panchayat chief) of Dhinkia called the meeting without being authorised by the gram panchayat, the state government said, adding it would take action against the sarpanch for transgressing his jurisdiction.
MoEF accepted the state government’s claims. But copies of the resolutions contradict what the Odisha government says (see ‘Resolutions belie Odisha government claims’). They show 1,638 people signed the resolution of Dhinkia and 1,265 people signed the resolution of Gobindpur. “The state government is lying. If not all, most of the villagers were present in the meeting,” says Prashant Paikrey, spokesperson for PPSS.