Whole of India needs anti-superstition law

State laws have been ineffective; Maharashtra hurriedly approves Ordinance to curb black magic and human sacrifice

By Kundan Pandey
Last Updated: Saturday 04 July 2015


In 21st century India, many people in rural as well as urban areas, would still rather consult a tantrik or an astrologer to cure their illnesses instead of approaching a doctor qualified for the job. In spite of the wide prevalence of superstition and irrational religious practices, including black magic, only three states have laws intended to deal with the social problem.

Bihar, Jharkhand and Chhattisgarh have enacted laws to restrict witchcraft. But these pieces of legislation have in no way helped to curb irrational beliefs and practices. A Dehradun-based organisation, Rural Litigation and Entitlement Kendra (RLEK), had filed a public interest petition in the Supreme Court in 2010 for proper implementation of these Acts. The petition claimed that more than 2,500 Indian women have been killed in the name of witchcraft in 15 years.

Related Blogs
A wake up call to the conscience of the nation
The murder of renowned rationalist Narendra Dabholkar is an attack on the Constitution of India and the principles enshrined in it
State of fear
Rationalist Narendra Dabholkar's murder is a reminder that social conditions give rise to irrationality and those who perpetuate existing inequities will go to any lengths to preserve their dominance
Chairperson of RLEK, Awadhesh Kaushal, says there is need for a strict national law which can stop black magic and witchcraft. Every state needs such an Act, he says. The most disturbing and least resisted forms of gender violence are taking place on the name of witch-hunts and witch-trials in many states, he says, while adding that the forms of violence includes torture, assault and rape.

Kaushal contends that the existing laws in the three states have failed to achieve their goal that includes protection of women. These laws have provision of imprisonment for three months and Rs 1,000 penalty. “This is not enough to deter people from engaging in superstitious practices,” he says. “If such practices result in loss of life, then it should be treated as a case of murder under the Indian Penal Code. Only stringent laws can yield results,” he adds. The Supreme Court, however, rejected the petition, informs Minakshi Arora, the lawyer who represented RLEK in the case.

A study—Report on Awareness & advocacy campaign against women’s exploitation in the name of witchcraft and land entitlement—claims that a total of 452 women have been brutally killed in Jharkhand from 2001 to 2008 in the name of witchcraft. The report was prepared by NGO Association for Social and Human Activities.

In June this year, the National Commission for Women (NCW) also emphasised on the need for a law which can curb violence against women in the name of black magic and witchcraft.

Maharashtra’s delayed action

The Maharashtra government, which has been delaying the enactment of the Maharashtra Prevention and Eradication of Human Sacrifice and other Inhuman Evil Practices and Black Magic Bill, meanwhile, hurriedly approved the anti-superstition and black magic Ordinance on Wednesday. The state Cabinet approved the Ordinance and forwarded it the governor for his signature. The Ordinance was in reaction to the killing of rationalist Narendra Dabholkar on August 20.  The doctor had championed the anti- superstition Bill from the beginning. The Bill has been pending in the state legislature since 2005. 

Dabholkar had established Andhashraddha Nirmoolan Samiti (ANS) to fight superstition in society. Deepak J Girme of ANS says the state law to curb human sacrifice and black magic should have been enacted long ago. “They kept the Bill pending on the pretext of amendments,” he says.

The Bill was first proposed in 1998 and passed in the Legislative Assembly in 2005, “but the so called intellectuals who sit in the legislative council kept the Bill on hold,” he alleges.

What the Maharashtra Ordinance says
The Ordinance approved by the Maharashtra Cabinet has 12 sections that spell out the crimes under the law. It provides for imprisonment of six months to seven years and fine of up to Rs 50,000. The crimes described in the Ordinance are as follows:
  1. Physical assault, torture, burning shocks, forcing a person to eat faecal matter in the name of driving out evil spirits or ghosts from the person’s body
  2. Cheating somebody on the name of miracles
  3. Any sinister (aghori) practice which endangers life or causes fatal injuries.
  4. Claims by persons of having supernatural powers and causing fear in the minds of others to cheat them
  5. To perform Karni, Bhanamati rituals and claiming possession of supernatural powers or advertising such claim
  6. To promise a woman that she will get child by claiming to possess supernatural powers or force her to have physical relations by claiming to be her spouse in previous birth
  7. To exploit mentally ill patients by claiming to possess supernatural powers
  8. To oppose scientific medical treatment and to coerce a person to accept aghori rituals when bitten by snake or dog or if the person is ill with cancer or other diseases
  9. Claims of performing surgery with fingers. Claims of guaranteeing birth of child of desired gender
  10. To isolate or punish someone by claiming he or she practices witchcraft or possesses evil power

Subscribe to Weekly Newsletter :

Comments are moderated and will be published only after the site moderator’s approval. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name. Selected comments may also be used in the ‘Letters’ section of the Down To Earth print edition.

  • But after presence of such a

    But after presence of such a law still there are lot of commercial black magicians in the town. How strange?

    Posted by: Anonymous | 5 years ago | Reply
  • Sir,
    I want to bring to your notice about a serial that promotes superstitious actions. I have already complained it to the Maharashtra superatition eradication committee and the IBF (Indian broadcasting foundation) TV officials months ago, who took no action on it. The serial's script and body itself is based on superstition. Especially the episode on aired on 17th march 2017. I have given the further details about the programme below. Hoping for your quick action.
    Thank you.

    Channel name: Zee Kannada
    Serial name: Mahadevi
    Timings: 8:30 pm - 9:00 pm (monday to friday)

    Posted by: Natraj Poojary | 3 years ago | Reply
  • I don't understand the basis of criminalizing the practices... not just because no proper reason is given for it but because the crimes in the ordinance look unrelated i.e. they don't follow a similar logic esp. points 7 & 10 when compared with others. It lacks consistency.

    on closer analysis it seems that the law is made not to stop irrational practices or help people develop a scientific temprament but it seems to be there only to protect some presumed 'rationals' who somehow resort to these practices or attempt to give it a try and fail to get positive results. That's to say, it will only help collect negative / failed cases without providing for a means for evaluating the rationality or validity of the practice.

    even the so-called scientific doctors fail to deliver the claims.... who decides for their performance to be more rational than others... ??

    i am not defending the so called 'superstitious' practices here - i know not much about them... but i am questioning the 'logic of the law' . it's science or the idea of 'being cheaters' or 'being insane' for propagating about something for which they don't have an explanation to give in the language of 'registered medical doctors'.

    I have to ask this question because I , as a qualified registered medical person have known people who have received positive results from these practices - while yeah... have seen the failed ones too.

    Posted by: Jyoti | one year ago | Reply