Review: ‘The Space Shuttle That Fell to Earth’ inspires critical conversations about safety, accountability in science

On February 1, 2003, United States’ National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) witnessed a tragedy — Space Shuttle Columbia and her crew of seven perished during re-entry on Earth 16 minutes prior to scheduled landing. Millions of people across the globe had been eagerly awaiting for Columbia’s landing and were devastated to hear about the loss. 

In India, the news was abuzz about Kalpana Chawla aboard the STS-107 mission. Chawla was the first woman of Indian descent to have gone to space in 1997. For many young Indians, like the pre-teen me, she was a beacon of success, motivation and ambition and the loss seemed personal.

Twenty-one years since then, a three-part BBC documentary, The Space Shuttle That Fell to Earth, talks to NASA and loved ones of the crew to tell the compelling and poignant journey of the mission and how it ended. 

While the mini-series chronicles the tragic events surrounding the 2003 Columbia disaster, the focus is not on the technical details of the accident, but rather the human impact. Through a touching blend of interviews, archival footage and emotional storytelling, it offers a powerful exploration of the loss of the seven astronauts and the profound effect it had on their families, colleagues and the US.

Interviews with the families of the astronauts offer heartbreaking glimpses into their grief and struggle to come to terms with the sudden loss. 

But even more importantly, the documentary features interviews with NASA engineers who made desperate attempts to raise an alarm about a crucial piece of information — approximately 82 seconds into the flight, a segment of foam insulation broke away from the shuttle’s external tank and appeared to impact Columbia’s left wing.

The mini-series shows the compelling perspective of the frustrated engineers trying to grapple with the management structure within NASA and the pressure to prioritise schedules over potential risks. It resonated with the universal human struggle between ambition and safety, a conflict we often witness in our own industries back home. 

As the engineers retell the story of their concerns and the failures of the managers to take it seriously, the frustration is still palpable in their narratives as they delve into the potential measures that could have prevented the disaster. Their internal conundrum over the technical and ethical implications of the accident was tangible and impactful. 

The makers of the mini-series made excellent use of archival footage throughout the programme, some of it previously unseen. Videos of the astronauts talking to their families transcends geographical barriers and the harrowing footage of debris scattered across Texas served as a constant reminder of the physical manifestation of the tragedy. 

Powerful and thought-provoking, The Space Shuttle That Fell to Earth is a tribute to the fallen astronauts and a reminder of the inherent risks involved in space exploration. By weaving together personal stories with a broader examination of the disaster, it compels viewers to contemplate the human cost of pushing the boundaries of knowledge and inspires critical conversations about safety and accountability in scientific endeavours. 

The documentary presents a stark reminder that the pursuit of scientific advancement, no matter how noble, should never come before the well-being of those involved.

We are a voice to you; you have been a support to us. Together we build journalism that is independent, credible and fearless. You can further help us by making a donation. This will mean a lot for our ability to bring you news, perspectives and analysis from the ground so that we can make change together.